Best key lime pie in Sarasota County

13 places serve it. Ranked by dish ratings (verified diners count most), then by the place’s overall rating.

1. 1BrewBurgersKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$7.99
2. 2Big Water Fish MarketMama’s Key Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$5.00
3. 3Spearfish Grill LLCkey lime pieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$10.00
4. 4The Sand Trap Sports Bar & GrillKey Lime Pie · Always a paradise favorite.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
5. 5Fat Daddio's PizzaMikes Key Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$5.61
6. 6GrillsmithKey Lime Pie · Scratch made key lime pie, pecan graham cracker crust, Nellie & Joe’s key lime juice, fresh whipped cream, house made raspberry sauceDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
7. 7Roessler's RestaurantKey Lime Pie · Graham Cracker Crust, Whipped CreamDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$9.00
8. 8British Open PubKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$10.00
9. 9Hurricane Grill and WingsKey Lime Pie · Made from fresh squeezed key limes with a graham cracker crust.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
10. 10Mattison’s City Grille SRQKEY LIME PIE · raspberry coulis, creme Chantilly, lime zest, fresh berriesDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
11. 11Casey Key Fish HouseKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.99
12. 12Tarpon Point Grill and MarinaKey Lime Pie · A homemade Florida favorite. Take a full pie home.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$9.00
13. 13Stottlemyer's SmokehouseKey Lime Pie · NoneDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.99