Best key lime colada in Sarasota

3 places serve it. Ranked by drink ratings (verified diners count most), then by the place’s overall rating.

1. 1Siesta Key Oyster BarKEY LIME COLADA · Captain Morgan Coconut Rum, Blue Chair Key Lime Rum, Tropeka Piña Colada Mix.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.50
2. 2O'Leary's Tiki Bar & GrillKey Lime Colada · classic piña colada with a J.F. Haden's key lime pie liqueur floaterDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$11.50
3. 3Gilligans Island Bar & GrillKey Lime Colada · A refreshing mix of Bacardi lime rum & pina colada, served on the rocks. 18oz stadium cup.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00