Best old fashion in Sarasota

40 places serve it. Ranked by drink ratings (verified diners count most), then by the place’s overall rating.

1. 1Smokin' Joe's SarasotaOld FashionedDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★
2. 2Bonefish GrillJefferson's Ocean "Aged at Sea" Old Fashioned · Jefferson's Ocean bourbon with Angostura bitters and a Bordeaux cherry, served over a colossal ice cubeDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00
3. 3Der DutchmanOld Fashioned NoodlesDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$39.99
4. 4Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse & Wine BarSIGNATURE SMOKED OLD FASHIONED · Basil Hayden Toast bourbon, Angostura bitters & house-made five-spice syrup 160 calDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$19.00
5. 5Cask and AleBanana Old Fashioned · Bulleit Bourbon, Giffard Banana Liqueur, orgeat, demerara & black walnut bittersDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00
6. 6MarcelMARCEL'S OLD FASHIONED · Nikka coffey grain whisky, plum & angostura bitters, agave syrupDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$18.95
7. 7Claytons Cafe and grilleNutty Old Fashioned · Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon with Angostura bitters, Frangelico, and a dark cherry garnish.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00
8. 8Hyde Park Prime SteakhouseBlack Cherry Old Fashioned · Old forester bourbon, amaretto di saronno, black cherry syrup, old fashioned bittersDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★
9. 9Owen's Fish CampOld Forester Old FashionedDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
10. 10ColumbiaCuban Old Fashioned · Papa's Pilar Oloroso Sherry Finished Rum with guava syrup and Angostura bitters. Served on the rocks with a twist of orange.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$16.00
11. 11Ed's TavernSpiced Old Fashioned · House-Made Spiced Simple Syrup with your choice of Broken Plank Dark Rum, Keeper's Heart Whiskey or Espolòn Reposado TequilaDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$13.00
12. 12Gecko'sFour Roses Small Batch Bourbon Old Fashioned or Manhattan on the RocksDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
13. 13Chef Rolf's New Florida Kitchen IncBlueberry Old Fashioned · Woodford Reserve bourbon / Angostura bitters / blueberry simple syrupDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00
14. 14KOJOOld Fashioned · 2.5 oz Bourbon or Rye, .50 oz Demerara Syrup, 2 d Ango, 1 d Orange Bitters. Method: Stir. Glass: DOF with a big cube. Garnish: Lemon and Orange Peel. aka Bunny Ears. I would use a little less sugar if the spirit is less than 90 proof.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★
15. 15Bridges RestaurantOld Fashion · Bulleit rye frontier whiskey smoked, demerara syrup, orange bitters, black walnut liqueur, garnished with filthy black cherries and an orange peelDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
16. 16Sage RestaurantOaxaca Old Fashioned · Tequila Reposado, Mezcal, Agave, Angostura & Xocolatl Mole BittersDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$20.00
17. 17The Melting PotOld Fashioned · A blend of Knob Creek Rye Whiskey, 18.21 Earl Grey Bitters and a brown sugar cube topped with an orange twist and a Filthy Black Cherry. Served chilled with a single large ice cube.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★
18. 18Gecko's Grill and PubFour Roses Small Batch Bourbon Old Fashioned or Manhattan on the RocksDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
19. 19Tebella Tea CompanyMasala Chai Old Fashioned Cocktail KitDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$21.00
20. 20Ocean Prime SarasotaOcean Prime Old Fashioned · Woodford Reserve, Bitters, OrangeDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$18.00
21. 21Gecko's Grill and PubFour Roses Small Batch Bourbon Old Fashioned or Manhattan on the RocksDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
22. 22Flemming's Prime SteakhouseSIGNATURE SMOKED OLD FASHIONED · Basil Hayden Toast bourbon, Angostura bitters & house-made five-spice syrup 160 calDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$19.00
23. 23Chart HouseThis is No 'Old' Fashioned · Woodford Reserve Bourbon, Carpano Antica Sweet Vermouth, San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa, Fee Brothers Orange Bitters (220 cal.)Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00
24. 24Christopher's On LidoApple Butter Old Fashioned · knob creek bourbon, apple juice, apple butter, orange bittersDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$20.00
25. 25The Lucky PelicanLouisville Old Fashioned · Elijah Craig Small Batch, Angostura bitters, simple syrup, water, orange, cherry.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
26. 26The Dark StarOld Fashioned · $8 Old FashionedDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
27. 27BrioBrio Old Fashioned · A classic crafted with Maker’s Mark Bourbon, Amaretto Disaronno, fresh orange, Italian cherries, & orange bitters, served over rocksDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
28. 28Giorgio's on HillviewStrawberry Basil Old FashionDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★
29. 29TIKI BAR at Chef Rolfs NFKBlueberry Old Fashioned · Woodford Reserve bourbon, Angostura bitters, blueberry simple syrup.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00
30. 30World of BeerMaple Old Fashioned · WhistlePig Piggyback 6 Year Rye, WhistlePig Barrel-Aged Maple Syrup, Angostura BittersDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$14.00
31. 31Main Bar Sandwich ShopOld Fashion Club Sandwich · Smoked ham & turkey on white toast with tomatoes, lettuce, mayonnaise & a dab of slawDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$14.75
32. 32ABO SarasotaOld FashionedDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$13.00
33. 33Lefty's Oyster & Seafood BarFOUR ROSES OLD FASHIONEDDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
34. 34Red Lobster"Old Salt's" Smoked Old Fashioned · Smoky bourbon and spiced brown sugar.Drink not rated yet · restaurant – ★
35. 35Bevardi’s Salute !New Old Fashioned · Woodford, simple, bitters, orange, cherries, clubDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00
36. 36Arts & CentralSmoked Old Fashioned · Michter's Bourbon, Demerara Sugar, Bitters, Smoked Under Hickory ChipsDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$14.00
37. 37Jpan Sushi and GrillOLD FASHIONEDDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$10.00
38. 38Tamiami TapThe Tap Old Fashioned · Michters rye, demerara cane sugar, bitters, orange bitters, muddled orange, dirty cherryDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$14.00
39. 39Charlie's Steak & HoagieGARY’S CHERRY WOOD SMOKED OLD FASHIONED · TOTT Redemption Bourbon, Angostura Bitters, Amarena Cherries, Orange PeelDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$23.00
40. 40Bonefish GrillJefferson's Ocean "Aged at Sea" Old Fashioned · Jefferson's Ocean bourbon with Angostura bitters and a Bordeaux cherry, served over a colossal ice cubeDrink not rated yet · restaurant – ★$15.00