Best peanut butter cookie in Sarasota

3 places serve it. Ranked by dish ratings (verified diners count most), then by the place’s overall rating.

1. 1Der DutchmanPeanut Butter Cookies-6PKDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$7.49
2. 2Barnes & Noble CaféPeanut Butter Cookie · For the true peanut butter lover. A delectable cookie loaded with creamy peanut butter and Reese's® peanut butter chips. Topped with chunks of Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups for a sensational experience.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
3. 3Five Star PizzaPeanut Butter Cookies!Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$1.99