Best peanut butter pie in Sarasota

6 places serve it. Ranked by dish ratings (verified diners count most), then by the place’s overall rating.

1. 1The Parrot Patio Bar & GrillPeanut Butter PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$9.00
2. 2Yoder‘s RestaurantChocolate Peanut Butter Pie · Served by the slice. À la mode add 2.00.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$7.95
3. 3Mattison's City GrillePEANUT BUTTER PIE · oreo crust, peanut butter cream, chocolate ganacheDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$10.00
4. 4Ocean Prime SarasotaCHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER PIE · Peanut Butter Mousse, Bittersweet Chocolate GanacheDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$19.00
5. 5Origin Pizza Cafe & craft beer: Rosemary DistrictPeanut Butter PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$10.00
6. 6Kacey's Seafood & MoreReese's Peanut Butter Pie · REESE'S® creamy peanut butter and then topped with chunks of REESE'S® Peanut Butter Cups. Placed in our rich chocolate cookie crust and drizzled with Hershey's® Dark Fudge Topping and Hershey's® Caramel.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.95