Best peanut butter pie in Tampa

5 places serve it. Ranked by dish ratings (verified diners count most), then by the place’s overall rating.

1. 1Paisano's Pizza & PastaPeanut Butter Pie · Reese's Pieces in a creamy peanut butter pie with chocolate chips. Drizzled with chocolate.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$6.99
2. 2Noble CrustPEANUT BUTTER PIE · Chocolate ganache, peanut pretzel crumbleDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$10.00
3. 3Crab ShackChocolate Peanut Butter PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$11.95
4. 4Slice of the BurgReesie Peanut Butter Pie · Gluten-free Oreo cookie base topped with a creamy peanut butter mix, finished with caramel and chocolate drizzle.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$6.99
5. 5Ranch House GrillReese's Peanut Butter PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$5.50