Mermaid Pies and Sandwiches

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Nov 5, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

Pies

Coconut Cream Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Chocolate Cream Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Peach Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Strawberry Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Mixed Berry Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Lemon Meringue Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Tomato Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Key West Crunch Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Chocolate Raisin Walnut Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Peanut Butter Truffle Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Pecan Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Key Lime Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Blueberry Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Cherry Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Apple Pie$5.95Not rated yet

Seafood

Prince Edward Island MusselsAsk10-pound minimumNot rated yet

Cold Water Bluepoint OystersAsk100 countNot rated yet

Steamer ClamsAsk10-pound minimum. Littlenecks middlenecks and topnecks 100 countNot rated yet

Live Maine (Hard Shell) LobsterAskFrom 1-8 poundsNot rated yet

Soups

Clam Chowder$6.95Not rated yet

Shrimp Corn Chowder$6.95Not rated yet

Lobster Bisque$8.95Not rated yet

Cookies

Peanut Butter$2.00Not rated yet

Chocolate Chip$2.00Not rated yet

Key Lime$2.00Not rated yet

Sandwiches

Lobster RollAskSweet Maine lobster lightly toasted with mayo chopped celery and scallion served on a butter toasted bun. Also available Connecticut style in hot butter.Not rated yet

Cuban Sandwich$15.95Traditional Tampa style Cuban pressedNot rated yet

The Mermaid$12.95Featuring house-made tuna salad served on top of a lettuce leaf in a toasted ciabatta rollNot rated yet

The Cortez$14.95Ham and cheese with sweet apricot spread and mayo pressed in a toasted rollNot rated yet

Sides

Cole Slaw$2.00Not rated yet

Black Bean Salad$2.00Not rated yet

Cape Cod Chips$2.00Not rated yet

Quiche

Lobster, Cream Cheese & Scallion Quiche$32.95Not rated yet

Quiche Lorraine Bacon, Ham & Swiss$22.95Not rated yet