Pie-licious Bake Shoppe

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 26, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

Pies

Pumpkin Pie$25.00made with fresh pumpkin!Not rated yet

Pumpkin Cream Pie$25.00Not rated yet

Cranberry-Apple Pecan Crumble$25.00Not rated yet

Sweet Potato Pie$25.00Not rated yet

Christmas Pie$25.00all the flavors and smells of the season:apples, dates, cranberries, cinnamon,nutmeg, pecansNot rated yet

Pear-Apple Crumble$25.00a crumb topping AND a pastry lattice!Not rated yet

All-American Apple Pie$25.00Not rated yet

Salted Caramel topped Apple Pie$25.00Not rated yet

Peanut Butter Pie$25.00Not rated yet

Southern Pecan Pie$25.00made with a touch of bourbon!Not rated yet

Pecan Cinnamon Roll Pie$25.00cinnamon-infused crust, topped with cream cheese icingNot rated yet

Butter Pecan-Toffee$25.00Not rated yet

Chocolate-Pecan$25.00featuring Ghirardelli chocolateNot rated yet

Mince Pie$25.00Not rated yet

Susie Strawberry$25.00Not rated yet

Strawberry/Rhubarb$25.00Not rated yet

Strawberry/ Mango$25.00Not rated yet

Strawberry /Peach$25.00Not rated yet

Eat a Peach$25.00Not rated yet

Raspberry Pie$25.00Not rated yet

My Award-Winning Mango Pie$25.00Not rated yet

Berry Medley$25.00It’s a Mixed Bag…Not rated yet

Blueberry$25.00I found my thrill… Maine blueberriesNot rated yet

Dark Sweet Cherry$25.00I cannot tell a lie…Not rated yet

Florida Key Lime$25.00Not rated yet

Lemon Meringue$25.00fresh squeezed lemon juice, lemon zestNot rated yet

Coconut Cream$25.00Not rated yet

Banana Cream$25.00chunks of fresh bananasNot rated yet

Ghirardelli Chocolate Cream$25.00Not rated yet

Specialty Pies

Gift-wrapped Pie$27.00Not rated yet

6-inch piesNot rated yet

Gift tray of 3 six-inch pies, boxed$40.00beautifully wrapped and tied with a bow! Choose from pumpkin, pecan, and apple (mix/match). (Available at Thanksgiving and Christmas only.)Not rated yet

Cookie Trays

Cookie Tray$40.00an assortment of 4 dozen cookies White Chocolate chip/dried cranberries,Chocolate Crinkles, Soft Ginger), OR 4-dozen of your choosing from the three varieties offered, arranged on a tray and gift-wrapped; presentation ready. (AVAILABLE YEAR-ROUND)Not rated yet

Boxed Assorted Homemade Cookies$25.00beautifully gift-boxed (3 dozen-Soft Ginger, White Christmas, and Chocolate Crinkle) (AVAILABLE AT THANKSGIVING & CHRISTMAS ONLY)Not rated yet

Soft Old-Fashioned GingerNot rated yet

White Christmaswhite chocolate chips with dried cranberriesNot rated yet

Chocolate Crinklea deep, soft chocolate cookie with mini chocolate chipsNot rated yet