I LOVE NY PIZZA

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 27, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

“Likely” diet labels: Based on the menu description, not checked by the restaurant. Tell the restaurant about any allergy before you order.

Food

Featured

Pasta Fazool Soup$5.99Not rated yet

Chicken Noodle Soup$5.99Not rated yet

Pizzas

Cheese Pizza$14.99Classic cheese or create your own pizza.Not rated yet

Pepperoni Pizza$16.99Not rated yet

Meat Lovers Pizza$21.99Pepperoni - Ham - Sausage - Meatballs - Bacon.Not rated yet

Hawaiian Pizza$17.99Ham - Pineapple.Not rated yet

Bianca (White)$18.99Mozzarella - Ricotta - Parmesan.Not rated yet

NY Supreme Pizza$22.99Green Peppers - Mushrooms - Onions - Black Olives - Pepperoni - Ham - Bacon - SausageNot rated yet

Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza$17.99Not rated yet

Bacon Delight Pizza$20.99Bacon - Onions - Fresh Tomatoes - Garlic.Not rated yet

Grandma Pie Pizza$24.99Thin Square Crust - Homemade Grandma Sauce - Fresh Mozzarella - Basil.Not rated yet

BBQ Chicken Pizza$21.99Breaded Chicken - BBQ Sauce - Fried Onions - Ranch Drizzle.Not rated yet

Boom Boom Pizza$20.99Pepperoni - Jalapenos - Mixed Cheese - Bacon.Not rated yet

Brooklyn Meatball Parm Pizza$21.99Meatballs - Mozzarella - Grandma Sauce.Not rated yet

Buffalo Chicken Pizza$21.99Breaded Chicken - Buffalo Sauce - Fresh Onions - Ranch Drizzle.Not rated yet

Clam Pie$19.99Not rated yet

Cheese Lovers Pizza$18.99Mozzarella - Ricotta - Cheddar - Parmesan.Not rated yet

Chicken Alfredo Pizza$21.99Grilled Chicken - Alfredo Sauce - Fresh Parsley.Not rated yet

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza$20.99Grilled Chicken - Bacon - Ranch.Not rated yet

Chicken Parm Pizza$21.99Breaded Chicken - Mozzarella - Parmesan.Not rated yet

Eggplant Parm Pizza$21.99Not rated yet

Joe Mama Pizza$21.99Grilled Chicken - Pesto - Fresh Mozzarella - Garlic - Fresh Tomatoes.Not rated yet

Margherita Pizza$19.99Fresh Mozzarella - Basil.Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Philly Steak & Cheese Pizza$20.99Philly Steak - Cheese - Pepper - Onions - Mushrooms.Not rated yet

Sammy the Goat Pizza$21.99Breaded Chicken - Vodka Sauce - Fresh Mozzarella - Basil.Not rated yet

Veggie Lovers Pizza$20.99Spinach - Green Peppers - Mushrooms - Onions - Fresh Tomatoes - Black Olives.Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Half & Half Pizza$0.01Not rated yet

Sicilian

Cheese Sicilian Pizza$24.99Not rated yet

Stuffed Pizzas

Meat Lovers Stuffed Pizza$29.99Pepperoni - Ham - Sausage - Bacon - Meatballs - Mozzarella - Parmigiano.Not rated yet

Chicken Parm Stuffed Pizza$29.99Chicken - Ham - Sausage - Bacon - Meatballs - Ricotta - Mozzarella - Parmigiano.Not rated yet

Florentine Stuffed Pizza$29.99Spinach - Mushrooms - Garlic - Ricotta - Mozzarella.Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Meatball Parm Stuffed Pizza$29.99Pepperoni - Ham - Sausage - Bacon - Meatballs - Ricotta - Mozzarella - Parmigiano.Not rated yet

Slices

NY Supreme Slice$5.99Green Peppers - Mushrooms - Onions - Black Olives - Pepperoni - Ham - Bacon - SausageNot rated yet

Sicilian Slice$4.99Not rated yet

Margherita Slice$5.99Not rated yet

BBQ Chicken Slice$5.99Not rated yet

Bianca (White) Slice$5.99Not rated yet

Pepperoni Slice$4.75Not rated yet

Veggie Lovers Slice$5.99Spinach - Green Peppers - Mushrooms - Onions - Fresh Tomatoes - Black OlivesNot rated yet

Buffalo Chicken Slice$5.99Not rated yet

Meat Lovers Slice$5.99Not rated yet

Hawaiian Slice$5.50Not rated yet

Cheese Slice$3.99Not rated yet

Sausage Slice$4.75Not rated yet

Grandma Slice$5.99Not rated yet

Appetizers

Bruschetta$7.99Not rated yet

Chicken Tenders$11.99Not rated yet

Fried Calamari$10.99Not rated yet

Breadsticks With Cheese$8.99Not rated yet

Mozzarella Sticks$8.995 Mozzarella sticks with a side of marinaraNot rated yet

Side Sausage$8.99Not rated yet

Side of Meatballs$8.99

Mussels Marinara$17.99Not rated yet

Garlic Knots With Cheese$7.99Not rated yet

Garlic Knots$5.99Not rated yet

Fries - Regular$5.99Not rated yet

Fries - Pizza$8.99Fries - Mozzarella - Bacon.Not rated yet

Fries - Truffle$7.99Not rated yet

NY Sampler$13.992 Mozzarella sticks - 2 Chicken Tenders - 4 Onion Rings.Not rated yet

Onion Rings$9.99Not rated yet

Salads

Caesar Salad$8.99Not rated yet

Antipasto Salad$15.99Not rated yet

Garden Salad$7.99Not rated yet

Avocado Salad$13.99Avocado - Fresh Mozzarella - BaconNot rated yet

Caprese Salad$13.99Not rated yet

Chef's Special Salad$13.99Ham - Turkey - Provolone.Not rated yet

Chicken Salad$13.99Grilled or BreadedNot rated yet

Greek Salad$12.99Feta Cheese - Kalamata Olives - Pepperoncini.Not rated yet

Hawaiian Salad$13.99Pineapple - Ham - Grilled Chicken.Not rated yet

Shrimp Salad$15.99Grilled or Breaded.Not rated yet

Tuna Salad$8.99Not rated yet

Wings

Wings$8.99Not rated yet

Calzones

Chicken Calzone$14.99Not rated yet

Meat Lovers Calzone$16.99Calzone: Pepperoni - Ham - Sausage - Bacon - Meatballs - Ricotta - Mozzarella - Parmigiano.Not rated yet

Cheese Calzone$13.99Mozzarella - Ricotta - Parmigiano.Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Pepperoni Calzone$14.99Calzone: Pepperoni - Mozzarella - Ricotta - Parmigiano.Not rated yet

Meatball Calzone$14.99Spinach - Mozarella - Ricotta - Parmigiano.Not rated yet

Ham Calzone$14.99Spinach - Mozzarella - Ricotta - Parmigiano.Not rated yet

Veggie Calzone$15.99Not rated yet

Spinach & Ricotta Calzone$14.99Spinach - Mozzarella - Ricotta - Parmigiano.Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Strombolis

Cheese Stromboli$12.99Mozzarella - Parmigiano.Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Pepperoni Stromboli$14.99Stromboli: Pepperoni.Not rated yet

Italian Stromboli$15.99Not rated yet

Philly Steak Stromboli$16.99Philly Steak - Green Peppers - Onions - Mushrooms.Not rated yet

Grilled Chicken Stromboli$15.99Stromboli: Grilled Chicken - Mushrooms - Green Peppers - Spinach - Black Olives.Not rated yet

Veggie Stromboli$15.99Green Peppers - Mushrooms - Onions - Spinach - Black Olives.Not rated yet

Sausage, Peppers & Onions Stromboli$16.99Not rated yet

Hot Off The Grill

Chicken Cutlet Sub$11.95Crispy chicken, mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, onion.Not rated yet

Buffalo Chicken Sub$12.95Crispy chicken, buffalo sauceNot rated yet

Philly Cheesesteak Sub$11.95Steak, onions, peppers, mushrooms, mozzarella.Not rated yet

BBQ Philly Cheesesteak Sub$12.95Steak, onions, peppers, mozzarella, BBQ sauce.Not rated yet

Philly Chicken Sub$11.95Chicken, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, mozzarella.Not rated yet

BBQ Chicken Sub$12.95Crispy chicken, onions, mozzarella, BBQ sauce.Not rated yet

Deli Subs

Italian Hero Sub$10.99Pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone cheeseNot rated yet

Ham & Cheese Sub$10.99Not rated yet

Meat Lover Sub$12.99Turkey, pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone cheese.Not rated yet

Parm Subs

Chicken Parm Sub$11.99Not rated yet

Eggplant Parm Sub$10.99Not rated yet

Meatball Parm Sub$11.99Not rated yet

Sausage, Peppers, Onion Parm Sub$11.99Not rated yet

Shrimp Parm Sub$13.99Not rated yet

Burgers

NY Cheeseburger$12.99¼ lb organic grass-fed Angus Beef patty on a bun with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.Not rated yet

Bacon Cheeseburger$12.99Not rated yet

BBQ Cheeseburger$12.99Not rated yet

Wraps

Buffalo Chicken Wrap$10.99Not rated yet

Chicken Caesar Wrap$12.99Not rated yet

Steak Wrap$10.99Green peppers, mushrooms, onions, mozzarellaNot rated yet

Chicken Caprese Wrap$10.99Chicken, pesto, mozzarella, balsamic glaze, lettuce, tomatoes, onionsNot rated yet

Gyros

Chicken Gyro$11.99Not rated yet

Beef Gyro$11.99Not rated yet

Pasta Dinners

Spaghetti with Meatballs$14.99Not rated yet

Spaghetti with Meat Sauce$14.99Not rated yet

Linguini Carbonara$16.99Not rated yet

Linguini Pesto$14.99Not rated yet

Penne Ala Vodka$16.99Not rated yet

Pasta Primavera$17.99Mixed peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomato sauce, broccoli, black olives, garlic wine sauce.Not rated yet

Baked Pasta

Baked Ziti$15.99Not rated yet

Baked Spaghetti$15.99Not rated yet

Cheese Ravioli$15.99Not rated yet

Manicotti$15.99Not rated yet

Pasta Trio$15.99Not rated yet

Stuffed Shells$15.99Not rated yet

Chicken Dinners

Chicken Alfredo$18.99Not rated yet

Chicken Francese$20.99Chicken cooked in a tangy lemon, butter, and caper sauce.Not rated yet

Chicken Marsala$20.99Chicken sautéed with mushrooms in a rich Marsala wine sauce.Not rated yet

Chicken Milanese$20.99Breaded and lightly fried, serves.Not rated yet

Chicken Piccata$20.99Chicken sautéed in a lemon-butter sauce.Not rated yet

Parm Dinners

Chicken Parm Dinner$16.99Lightly fried and topped with mozzarella and our homemade sauce. Served with choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccine, Ziti.Not rated yet

Eggplant Parm Dinner$16.99Lightly fried and topped with mozzarella and our homemade sauce. Served with choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccine, Ziti.Not rated yet

Eggplant Rolatini Dinner$16.99Lightly fried and topped with mozzarella and our homemade sauce. Served with choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccine, Ziti.Not rated yet

Sausage Parm Dinner$15.99Lightly fried and topped with mozzarella and our homemade sauce. Served with choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccine, Ziti.Not rated yet

Shrimp Parm Dinner$19.99Lightly fried and topped with mozzarella and our homemade sauce. Served with choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccine, Ziti.Not rated yet

Seafood Dinners

Linguini Clam Sauce$21.99Sautéed clams in red or white sauce over linguini.Not rated yet

Seafood Combo$24.99Mussels, shrimps, clams, calamari.Not rated yet

Shrimp Alfredo$21.99Shrimp in one fettuccine Alfredo sauce.Not rated yet

Shrimp Marinara$21.99Shrimp in homemade marinara over linguini.Not rated yet

Kids Menu

Kids Chicken Tenders with Fries$8.99Not rated yet

Kids Spaghetti with Meat Sauce$7.99Not rated yet

Kids Spaghetti with Meatballs$7.99Not rated yet

Kids Spaghetti with Butter$6.99Not rated yet

Kids Mickey Mouse Pizza$8.99With 1 topping.Not rated yet

Homemade Desserts

Cannoli$7.99Not rated yet

Gelato$3.99Not rated yet

Nutella Calzone$8.99Not rated yet

NY Cheesecake$5.99Not rated yet

Panna Cotta$6.99Not rated yet

Strawberry Cheesecake$6.99Not rated yet

Tiramisu$7.99Not rated yet

Zeppole$6.99Not rated yet

Red Velvet Cake$7.99Not rated yet

Chocolate Mousse Cake$5.99Not rated yet

Pizza Specials

Pizza Special$10.99Choose two Specialty Slices x $10.99 plus SodaNot rated yet

Pizza Special$8.99Choose Two Slices (Cheese or Pepperoni) plus Can of sodaNot rated yet

Pizza Special$9.99Choose two Slices x $10.99 plus SodaNot rated yet

Drinks

Beverages

Canned Soda$2.25Not rated yet

Bottle Water$2.25Not rated yet

2L Bottle$5.75Not rated yet