Jeremiah's Italian Ice

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 27, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

Flavorites

Pumpkin PieAskThe perfect layering of Pumpkin Pie Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Crea...Not rated yet

GrasshopperAskThe perfect layering of Scoop Froggy Frog Italian Ice, Cookies and Cre...Not rated yet

Strawberry ShortcakeAskThe perfect layering of Strawberry Italian Ice, Cake Batter Italian Ic...Not rated yet

Blue Razz CrunchAskThe perfect layering of Blue Razz Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream,...Not rated yet

Frosted Animal CrackerAskThe perfect layering of Cotton Candy Italian Ice, Cookie Butter Italia...Not rated yet

S'MoreAskThe perfect layering of Cookie Butter Italian Ice, Chocolate Italian I...Not rated yet

Sugar CookieAskThe perfect layering of Cake Batter Italian Ice, Cookie Butter Italian...Not rated yet

PB & JAskThe perfect layering of Strawberry Italian Ice, P-Nutty Italian Ice, V...Not rated yet

Peanut Butter CupAskThe perfect layering of P-Nutty Italian Ice, Chocolate Soft Ice Cream,...Not rated yet

Oreo Mud PieAskThe perfect layering of Cookies and Cream Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ic...Not rated yet

Birthday CakeAskThe perfect layering of Cake Batter Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Crea...Not rated yet

Orange Mango TangoAskThe perfect layering of Mango Italian Ice, Orange Smash Italian Ice, V...Not rated yet

Candy BarAskThe perfect layering of P-Nutty Italian Ice, Salted Caramel Italian Ic...Not rated yet

Caramel AppleAskThe perfect layering of Sour Apple Italian Ice, Salted Caramel Italian...Not rated yet

Spiced MangoAskThe perfect layering of Mango Italian Ice, Vanilla Ice Cream, Tajin & ...Not rated yet

Build-Your-Own FlavoriteAskBuild your own perfect layering of authentic Italian Ice, indulgent So...Not rated yet

Jelati

Tadpole Mini Jelati$4.19The perfect layering of Italian Ice & Soft Ice Cream!Not rated yet

Small Jelati$4.59The perfect layering of Italian Ice & Soft Ice Cream!Not rated yet

Medium Jelati$5.59The perfect layering of Italian Ice & Soft Ice Cream!Not rated yet

Bullfrog Jelati$6.59The perfect layering of Italian Ice & Soft Ice Cream!Not rated yet

Quart Jelati$8.99The perfect layering of Italian Ice & Soft Ice Cream!Not rated yet

Jelati Cakes (48 Hrs Req)

Frosted Animal Cracker Jelati Cake$29.99Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A B...Not rated yet

Oreo® Mud Pie Jelati Cake$29.99Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A B...Not rated yet

Strawberry Shortcake Jelati Cake$29.99Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A B...Not rated yet

Birthday Cake Jelati Cake$29.99Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A B...Not rated yet

Build-Your-Own Jelati Cake$29.99Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with refreshing Italia...Not rated yet

Pumpkin Pie Jelati Cake$29.99Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with refreshing Italia...Not rated yet

Italian Ice

Tadpole Mini Italian Ice$2.99Refreshing & Indulgent - Made Fresh Daily!Not rated yet

Small Italian Ice$3.59Refreshing & Indulgent - Made Fresh Daily!Not rated yet

Medium Italian Ice$4.59Refreshing & Indulgent - Made Fresh Daily!Not rated yet

Bullfrog Italian Ice$5.59Refreshing & Indulgent - Made Fresh Daily!Not rated yet

Quart Italian Ice$7.99Refreshing & Indulgent - Made Fresh Daily!Not rated yet

Soft Ice Cream

Tadpole Mini Soft Ice Cream$3.99Certified Rich & Creamy!Not rated yet

Small Soft Ice Cream$4.39Certified Rich & Creamy!Not rated yet

Medium Soft Ice Cream$5.39Certified Rich & Creamy!Not rated yet

Bullfrog Soft Ice Cream$6.39Certified Rich & Creamy!Not rated yet

Quart Soft Ice Cream$8.99Certified Rich & Creamy!Not rated yet

Ice Cream Sandwiches

6 Pack - Ice Cream Sandwiches$14.99The perfect handheld treat on-the-go!Not rated yet

Classic Ice Cream Sandwich$2.99The perfect handheld treat on-the-go!Not rated yet

Chocolate Chips Ice Cream Sandwich$2.99The perfect handheld treat on-the-go!Not rated yet

Rainbow Sprinkles Ice Cream Sandwich$2.99The perfect handheld treat on-the-go!Not rated yet

Extras

Bottled Water$2.25

Waffle Cone on the Side$0.99

Small Cooler Bag$6.99