KitchenSpot
Search
See the best dishes near you?
← Sarasota County restaurants

Casey Key Fish House

No reviews yet

Seafood801 Blackburn Point Rd, Osprey

Call Directions Website

Own or manage Casey Key Fish House? Claim this listing free

MenuReviews · 0Photos · 0Hours & info

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 26, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks.

Food

HOME MADE SOUPS

New England Clam ChowderNew England Clam Chowder$8.99Not rated yet
Soup of the DaySoup of the Day$8.99Not rated yet

SIDES

Garlic BreadGarlic Bread$3.99Not rated yet
Side FriesSide Fries$3.99Not rated yet

Side of Veggies$3.99

Side of Home Made Cole Slaw$3.99

SALADS

Caesar SaladCaesar Salad$10.99Not rated yet
House Spring MixHouse Spring Mix$9.99Italian, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey MustardNot rated yet

Caesar or House Salads with:

Chicken$16.99

Mahi$18.99

Grouper or Shrimp$19.99

DESSERTS

Key Lime PieKey Lime Pie$8.99Not rated yet
Dessert of the DayDessert of the Day$8.99Not rated yet

APPETIZERS

Mussels MarinaraMussels Marinara$14.99Prince Edward Island Mussels in homemade marinara sauce with garlic breadNot rated yet
MusselsMussels$15.99Prince Edward Island Mussels sautéed in white wine and garlic, and with garlic breadNot rated yet
U-Peel U-Eat ShrimpU-Peel U-Eat Shrimp$13.99Fresh, chilled shrimp, served with fresh lemon and cocktail sauceNot rated yet
U-Peel, Garlic Shrimp - Served warmU-Peel, Garlic Shrimp - Served warm$14.99Sautéed in fresh garlicNot rated yet
Buffalo WingsBuffalo Wings$14.99Lightly fried, Plump & Juicy Shrimp - they're best! Served with carrots, celery sticks, blue cheese / hot sauce on the sideNot rated yet
CalamariCalamari$14.99Baby calamari, lightly breaded and fried to perfection. Served with home made marinara sauceNot rated yet
Onion RingsOnion Rings$12.99Sweet onion, deep fried to perfectionNot rated yet
Conch FrittersConch Fritters$14.99A blend of our special seasonings, fried to a golden brown. Served with tartar sauceNot rated yet
Crab CakesCrab Cakes$15.99Two crab cakes homemade with blue crabmeat, chopped sweet red bell peppers and stuffing, seasoned to perfection and topped with That Chili GlazeNot rated yet
Smoked Mahi Fish DipSmoked Mahi Fish Dip$14.99Served with CrackersNot rated yet
Coconut ShrimpCoconut Shrimp$14.99Served with orange marmalade sauceNot rated yet

BASKETS

All baskets include: Fries (or) home made Cole slaw, Lettuce and Tomato on all sandwichsAsk

ExtraAsk

Grouper SandwichGrouper Sandwich$20.99Not rated yet
Mahi Mahi SandwichMahi Mahi Sandwich$19.99Your choice of Blackened, Grilled or FriedNot rated yet
Cod Fish & ChipsCod Fish & Chips$17.99Not rated yet
Battered ShrimpBattered Shrimp$17.99Not rated yet
Crab CakesCrab Cakes$19.99Not rated yet
Char-Grilled Burger, 1/2 lb.Char-Grilled Burger, 1/2 lb.$15.99Not rated yet
Black Bean BurgerBlack Bean Burger$13.99Not rated yet
Chicken FingersChicken Fingers$13.99Not rated yet
Beef Dog, 1/4 lb.Beef Dog, 1/4 lb.$11.99Not rated yet
Battered Dog, 1/4 lb. Deep-fried beer batterBattered Dog, 1/4 lb. Deep-fried beer batter$12.99Not rated yet

CHILDREN'S (under 10)

Fish and Chips (1 piece)Fish and Chips (1 piece)$8.99Not rated yet
Hot dog and friesHot dog and fries$8.99Not rated yet
Grilled cheese with friesGrilled cheese with fries$8.99Not rated yet
Chicken Fingers with friesChicken Fingers with fries$8.99Not rated yet
Pasta with butter or Marinara saucePasta with butter or Marinara sauce$8.99Not rated yet

DINNERS (After 4:00PM)

Grouper, Pan searedGrouper, Pan seared$34.99with white wine and tropical fruit salsa, with starch and sautéed hash brownsNot rated yet
Sesame Crusted Pan Seared TunaSesame Crusted Pan Seared Tuna$34.99Over Asian stir fried noodles with Ginger Soy Sauce & WasabiNot rated yet
Baked Stuffed Shrimp w/ Crab MeatBaked Stuffed Shrimp w/ Crab Meat$33.99Not rated yet
Fresh Grilled SalmonFresh Grilled Salmon$29.99Topped with cucumber dill sauce served with starch and sautéed fresh vegetablesNot rated yet
Fresh Grilled Mahi-MahiFresh Grilled Mahi-Mahi$30.99with shrimp, sun-dried tomato, artichoke and mushroom, Served with starch and sautéed fresh vegetablesNot rated yet
Seafood PastaSeafood Pasta$33.99Shrimp, scallops, grouper and Mussels, with fresh basil tomato sauce served over pastaNot rated yet
Shrimp ScampiShrimp Scampi$27.99Sautéed shrimp, garlic, in a white wine sauce Served over pastaNot rated yet
Mussels with PastaMussels with Pasta$26.99Your choice of white garlic or marinara sauceNot rated yet
Diver Scallops with Citrus SauceDiver Scallops with Citrus Sauce$36.99Served with starch and sautéed fresh vegetablesNot rated yet
Almond Snapper, Pan Seared$32.99Encrusted with almonds & topped with a lemon butter sauce. Served with starch and sautéed fresh vegetablesNot rated yet
New York Strip - Angus Beef 14 ozNew York Strip - Angus Beef 14 oz$33.99Hand-cut, served with wild mushroom Cabernet demi glaze, starch and sautéed fresh vegetablesNot rated yet
Sautéed Chicken BreastSautéed Chicken Breast$27.99Served with artichokes, mushrooms, tomato, starch, and sautéed fresh vegetables.Not rated yet

SALADS

Caesar or House Salads with: ChickenCaesar or House Salads with: Chicken$16.99Your choice of Blackened, Grilled, FriedNot rated yet
Caesar or House Salads with: MahiCaesar or House Salads with: Mahi$18.99Your choice of Blackened, Grilled, FriedNot rated yet
Caesar or House Salads with: Grouper or ShrimpCaesar or House Salads with: Grouper or Shrimp$19.99Your choice of Blackened, Grilled, FriedNot rated yet

BASKETS

Mahi SandwichMahi Sandwich$19.99Your choice of Blackened, Grilled or FriedNot rated yet
Char-Grilled Burger, 1/2 lbChar-Grilled Burger, 1/2 lb$15.99Not rated yet
Chicken Breast Char-Grilled SandwichChicken Breast Char-Grilled Sandwich$14.99Not rated yet
Beef Dog, 1/4 lb$11.99Not rated yet
Battered Dog, 1/4lb$12.99Deep fried beer batter.Not rated yet

DINNER SSSSSSSS (After 4:00PM)

New York Strip—Angus Beef 14 oz.$33.99Hand-cut, served with wild mushroom Cabernet demi glaze, starch and sautéed fresh veggiesNot rated yet

CHILDREN’S

Fish and Chips ( 1 piece)Fish and Chips ( 1 piece)$8.99Not rated yet

APPETIZERS

Peel- U Eat ShrimpPeel- U Eat Shrimp$13.99Fresh, chilled shrimp, served with fresh lemon and cocktail sauceNot rated yet
Peel, Garlic Shrimp ———— Served warmPeel, Garlic Shrimp ———— Served warm$14.99Sautéed in fresh garlicNot rated yet
Buffalo shrimpBuffalo shrimp$14.99Lightly fried, Plump & Juicy Shrimp - they’re the best! Served with carrots, celery sticks, blue cheese / hot sauce on the sideNot rated yet

Extras

Cheese, sautéed onion, mushroom, bacon, sauerkraut, sauces or dip$2.00

Drinks

BEVERAGES

Soft Drink w/ RefillSoft Drink w/ Refill$3.50Not rated yet
Coffee w/ RefillCoffee w/ Refill$3.50Not rated yet
Ice Tea w/ RefillIce Tea w/ Refill$3.50Not rated yet
Juice (No Refill)Juice (No Refill)$4.00Not rated yet

BEVERAGES

SoftDrink w/ Refill$3.50Not rated yet
Ice Tea w/Refill$3.50Not rated yet