Caribbean Pie Company

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 25, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

SHOP WHAT'S NEW!

Chocolate-Drizzle Key Lime Bites (Dozen)AskNot rated yet

Graham Crumble Key Lime Bites (Dozen)AskNot rated yet

Orange Dreamsicle PieAskNot rated yet

Tropical Fruit Key Lime PieAskNot rated yet

Menu

Classic Key Lime PieAskFor more than 35 years, our signature Key Lime Pie has been a Sarasota favorite. Silky smooth, refreshingly tart, and nestled in a golden graham cracker crust, every pie is handcrafted using the same beloved recipe that earned us the 2023 People's Choice Award for Best Pie in Sarasota. It's not just dessert—it's a taste of Florida tradition.Not rated yet

Florida's Favorite, On a StickAskOur award-winning Key Lime Pie gets a fun new twist. Made with the same tangy key lime filling and buttery graham cracker crust that earned Sarasota's 2023 People's Choice Award, this hand-held treat delivers the perfect balance of sweet and citrusy flavor in every bite.Not rated yet