Der Dutchman

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 30, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

“Likely” diet labels: Based on the menu description, not checked by the restaurant. Tell the restaurant about any allergy before you order.

Food

Featured Items

Snickerdoodle Cookies-6PK$7.49Not rated yet

Long Johns

Coffee & Donut Special$3.99Start your day right with a fresh donut paired with a hot cup of our freshly brewed coffee—simple, comforting, and always satisfying.Not rated yet

Caramel Long John$2.99Golden-fried yeast doughnut filled with fluffy vanilla cream and topped with rich, buttery caramel icing. A classic long john that’s sweet, smooth, and downright irresistible.Not rated yet

Chocolate Long John$2.99Soft, golden yeast doughnut filled with fluffy vanilla cream and finished with a thick layer of rich chocolate icing. A timeless bakery favorite that never disappoints.Not rated yet

Vanilla Long John$2.99Light, fluffy yeast doughnut filled with smooth vanilla cream and topped with a sweet vanilla icing. Simple, classic, and perfectly satisfying.Not rated yet

Donuts

Coffee & Donut Special$3.99Start your day right with a fresh donut paired with a hot cup of our freshly brewed coffee—simple, comforting, and always satisfying.Not rated yet

Apple Fritter$2.99Golden-fried dough packed with tender apple pieces and warm cinnamon, finished with a sweet vanilla glaze. Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and loaded with old-fashioned flavor.Not rated yet

Glazed Cinnamon Twist$2.99Soft, twisted yeast dough rolled in cinnamon and sugar, then finished with a sweet glaze. Light, fluffy, and perfectly spiced in every bite.Not rated yet

Sugar Cinnamon Twist$2.99Light, fluffy twisted yeast dough coated generously in cinnamon and sugar. Warm, sweet, and a classic favorite for any time of day.Not rated yet

Glazed Donut$2.29Light and airy yeast doughnut fried to golden perfection and coated in a smooth, sweet glaze. A simple classic that’s always a crowd-pleaser.Not rated yet

Bakery

Butterscotch Cream Pie-LG$17.49Not rated yet

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Pie-LG$17.49Not rated yet

Chocolate Cream Pie-LG$17.49Not rated yet

Coconut Cream Pie-LG$17.49Not rated yet

Peanut Butter Cream Pie-LG$17.49Not rated yet

White Dinner Rolls-12PK$5.49Not rated yet

White Dinner Rolls-6PK$4.49Not rated yet

Wheat Dinner Rolls-12PK$5.49Not rated yet

Wheat Dinner Rolls-6PK$4.49Not rated yet

Der Dutchman Peanut Butter Spread$5.99

Der Dutchman Apple Butter$3.99

Chocolate Chip Cookies-6PK$7.49Not rated yet

Chocolate Crinkle Cookies-6PK$7.49Not rated yet

Iced Buttermilk Cookies-6PK$8.49Not rated yet

M & M Cookies-6PK$7.49Not rated yet

Monster Cookies-6PK$7.49Not rated yet

Peanut Butter Cookies-6PK$7.49Not rated yet

Snickerdoodle Cookies-6PK$7.49Not rated yet

Dinner Buffets

Meatballs$2.79Choose BBQ or Sweet & Sour.Not rated yet

Chicken Tenders$2.99Choose two sauces—BBQ, Sweet & Sour, Ranch or Honey Mustard.Not rated yet

Chicken Wings$2.79Choose Hot, BBQ or Sweet & Sour.Not rated yet

Fresh Fruit Tray$2.99Assortment of fresh seasonal fruit. Served with special fruit dip.Not rated yet

Fresh Vegetable Tray$2.79Assortment of fresh vegetables. Served with ranch dip.Not rated yet

Cheese Tray$2.49Assortment of cubed hot pepper, Swiss, marble and Colby cheese. Served with crackers.Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Shrimp Cocktail$7.29Served with lemon wedges and cocktail sauce.Not rated yet

Broasted Chicken 16 pc$37.49All white or dark meat, add 25%Not rated yet

Broasted Chicken 24 pc$52.99All white or dark meat, add 25%Not rated yet

Broasted Chicken 48 pc$102.99All white or dark meat, add 25%Not rated yet

Baked Ham, Roast Pork, Per pound$15.49Not rated yet

Roast Turkey Per pound$17.49Not rated yet

Roast Beef Per pound$19.49Not rated yet

Gravy - Beef or Chicken Quart$8.49

Gravy - Beef or Chicken Gallon$29.99

Real Mashed Potatoes$39.99Not rated yet

Red Parsley Potatoes$39.99Not rated yet

Homemade Dressing$39.99Not rated yet

Broccoli$39.99Not rated yetLikely Vegan

Gourmet Veggies$39.99Not rated yet

Green Beans$39.99Not rated yet

Old Fashioned Noodles$39.99Not rated yet

Creamed Corn$39.99Not rated yet

Macaroni & Cheese$39.99Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Seasoned Rice$39.99Not rated yet

Baby Carrots$39.99Not rated yet

Candied Sweet Potatoes$39.99Not rated yet

Gourmet Mashed Potatoes$39.99Not rated yet

Fresh Fruit$39.99Not rated yet

Scalloped Potatoes$39.99Not rated yet

Potato Salad$39.99Not rated yet

Three-Bean Salad$39.99Not rated yet

Coleslaw$39.99Not rated yet

Broccoli & Cauliflower Salad$39.99Not rated yet

Garden Salad$45.99Not rated yet

Strawberry Poppyseed Salad$45.99Not rated yet

Fruit Pies$18.49Ask about our Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pies!Not rated yet

Cream Pies$17.49Not rated yet

No Sugar Added Pies$18.99Not rated yet

Premium Pies$19.49Not rated yet

Cookies$13.99DozenNot rated yet

Brownies$9.998x8 TrayNot rated yet

Assorted Bars$19.99DozenNot rated yet

Sheet Cakes$54.99Decorating includedNot rated yet

Homemade Rolls$5.49DozenNot rated yet

Breakfast

Emanuel’s Favorite$14.49Buttermilk biscuit with sausage gravy, two eggs, hash browns, choice of meat, and homemade toastNot rated yet

Sugarcreek Breakfast$13.49Two pieces mush, two eggs, and choice of meatNot rated yet

Amish Scramble$14.49Scrambled eggs served with a combination of ham and hash browns, topped with melted cheese and served with homemade toastNot rated yet

Bellville Barn-Raiser$13.49Two eggs, hash browns, choice of meat, and homemade toastNot rated yet

Walnut Creek Breakfast$11.49Two eggs, choice of meat, and homemade toastNot rated yet

Sarasota Sunrise$11.49Two eggs, side of fresh fruit, and homemade toastNot rated yet

Plain City Breakfast$10.79Two eggs, hash browns, and toastNot rated yet

Middlebury Breakfast$11.49Two biscuits and hash browns covered with sausage gravyNot rated yet

Nappanee Starter$6.99Two eggs prepared your way with homemade toastNot rated yet

Eggs Benedict$14.49Served with hash browns or gritsNot rated yet

Dutch Haus Sandwich$10.49Egg, choice of meat, and cheese on croissant or choice of breadNot rated yet

Homemade Biscuits & Gravy$9.49Creamy, homemade sausage or tomato gravy ladled over fresh-baked buttermilk biscuitsNot rated yet

Cornmeal Mush$7.49Crispy, golden slices of fried cornmeal mush served with warm syrupNot rated yet

Hot Oatmeal or Grits$5.49BowlNot rated yet

Pancakes$5.99One - 5.99, Two - 7.99. With blueberries or chocolate chips - .99Not rated yet

Farmstead Breakfast$13.99Two pancakes, two eggs, and choice of meatNot rated yet

French Toast$5.99Thick slices of our homemade bread, sprinkled with powdered sugar, and served with warm syrupNot rated yet

Kids Menu

Cookie$1.69Not rated yet

Ice Cream$2.99Not rated yet

Sundae$3.79Chocolate, CaramelNot rated yet

Small Beverage$2.49Pepsi, Lemonade, Diet Pepsi, White Milk, Mountain Dew, Chocolate Milk, Dr. Pepper, Starry, Apple Juice, Root Beer, Orange JuiceNot rated yet

Chicken$8.99Choose 2 legs, 2 tenders or a boneless chicken breast (add $1)Not rated yet

Roast Turkey$8.99Not rated yet

Roast Beef$9.99Not rated yet

Mini Corn Dogs$8.99Not rated yet

Macaroni & Cheese$8.99Not rated yet

Grilled Cheese$8.99Not rated yet

Cheeseburger$8.99Not rated yet

Mashed Potatoes$3.29Not rated yet

French Fries$3.29Not rated yet

Noodles$3.29Not rated yet

Mac & Cheese$3.29Not rated yet

Creamed Corn$3.29Not rated yet

Green Beans$3.29Not rated yet

Coleslaw$3.29Not rated yet

Applesauce$3.29Not rated yet

Tossed Salad$3.79add .50Not rated yet

Cottage Cheese$3.29Not rated yet

Fresh Fruit$3.79add .50Not rated yet

Drinks

Cafe Drinks Menu

Regular Coffee$3.49House blend – from our dining roomNot rated yet

Vanilla Chai Tea$5.79A comforting blend of spiced chai tea and creamy milk, finished with smooth vanillaNot rated yet

Iced Coffee$3.29Freshly brewed coffee served over ice—smooth and refreshingNot rated yet

Americano Coffee$4.49Espresso diluted with hot water for a smooth, coffee-style tasteNot rated yet

6:01am$4.49Dutchman Signature Blend, EspressoNot rated yet

Espresso$3.49Freshly brewed espresso—intense and robustNot rated yet

Chai Tea$5.29Black Tea, spices, milk; served hot or cold.Not rated yet

Cold Brew$6.49Coffee slow steeped at room temp for a bold, smooth taste served over ice and topped with sweet cream.Not rated yet

London Fog$4.79Earl Grey tea with milk and vanilla—delicious served hot or icedNot rated yet

Macchiato$5.79Strong espresso softened with just a hint of milkNot rated yet

Cafe Cappuccino$4.99Espresso, frothed milk.Not rated yet

Deluxe Cappuccino$5.79Espresso, frothed milk with shot of flavor of choice.Not rated yet

Hot Chocolate$4.79Creamy, rich chocolate blended with steamed milk and topped with whipped creamNot rated yet

Deluxe Hot Cocoa$4.99Rich Chocolate Sauce, steamed milk, topped with whip toppingNot rated yet

Cafe Latte$5.79Rich espresso blended with steamed milkNot rated yet

Deluxe Latte$5.99Espresso, steamed milk, syrup flavor of your choiceNot rated yet

Cinnamon Dolce Latte$6.49Espresso, vanilla syrup, cinnamon syrup, steamed milk, whipped creamNot rated yet

Chocolate Hazelnut Latte$6.49Like Nutella®? Try this! Espresso, chocolate sauce, hazelnut syrup, steamed milk, whipped creamNot rated yet

Chocolate Coconut Latte$6.49Rich espresso blended with creamy coconut and smooth chocolateNot rated yet

Salted Caramel Mocha$6.49Espresso, caramel and chocolate sauce, steamed milk, whipped cream sprinkled with sea saltNot rated yet

Brown Sugar Latte$6.49A creamy latte sweetened with rich brown sugar for a comforting finishNot rated yet

White Chocolate Mocha$6.49Espresso, white chocolate sauce, steamed milk, whipped creamNot rated yet

Dutch Mocha$6.49Espresso, chocolate sauce, steamed milk, whipped creamNot rated yet

Caramel & Vanilla Latte$6.49A creamy caramel latte with a touch of vanilla for extra richness and sweetness—perfect as a cozy indulgenceNot rated yet

Caramel Latte$6.49Smooth espresso with milk and caramel—lightly sweet and comfortingNot rated yet

Drink of the Month$6.49Not rated yet

Sarasota Tropical Smoothie$6.99Sun-kissed pineapple, mango, orange and banana come together in a creamy, island-inspired smoothie that’s bright, smooth, and refreshing.Not rated yet

Four Berry Blend Smoothie$6.99A smooth, refreshing mix of strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries, bursting with natural fruity flavor.Not rated yet

Pineapple Paradise Smoothie$6.99A tropical blend of juicy pineapple, perfectly smooth and bursting with sweet, sunny flavor.Not rated yet

Mango Tropic Smoothie$6.99A tropical blend of ripe mangoes, perfectly smooth with a naturally sweet and sunny flavor.Not rated yet

Strawberry Smoothie$6.99Juicy strawberries blended smooth for a naturally sweet and refreshing drink.Not rated yet

Strawberry-Banana Smoothie$6.99A classic combo of sweet strawberries and creamy bananas blended smooth for a refreshingly fruity treat.Not rated yet