Old Key West Bar And Grill Llc

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Nov 4, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

Food

Appetizers

Conch Fritters$12.00Golden fried conch with spicy remoulade and lime aioliNot rated yet

Shrimp Ceviche$14.00Citrus-marinated shrimp with avocado, jalapeño, and crispy tortilla chipsNot rated yet

Grilled Scallops$16.00Pan-seared diver scallops with garlic butter and microgreensNot rated yet

Coconut Crusted Shrimp$13.00Toasted coconut shrimp with sweet chili dipping sauceNot rated yet

Main Courses

Mahi-Mahi Delmonico$28.00Grilled mahi-mahi fillet with key lime butter, served with rice and seasonal vegetablesNot rated yet

BBQ Ribs Platter$26.00Slow-smoked St. Louis ribs glazed with signature sauce, served with coleslaw and cornbreadNot rated yet

Key West Lobster Tail$35.0012 oz. Maine lobster tail with drawn butter, served with loaded baked potatoNot rated yet

Pan-Seared Red Snapper$30.00Locally-caught red snapper with tropical mango salsa and jasmine riceNot rated yet

NY Strip Steak$32.0016 oz. USDA Prime steak with herb butter, served with truffle fries and grilled asparagusNot rated yet

Drinks

Signature Cocktails

Tropical Sunset$12.00Light rum, pineapple juice, mango purée, fresh lime, and a splash of grenadineNot rated yet

Island Mojito$11.00White rum, fresh mint, lime, coconut cream, and a hint of rum barrel oakNot rated yet

Key West Mai Tai$13.00Premium rum blend, orgeat, lime juice, and a float of dark rumNot rated yet

Spiced Pineapple Punch$12.00Spiced rum, fresh pineapple juice, lime, and a touch of hazelnut liqueurNot rated yet