Casa Santo Stefano

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 10, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

Food

Antipasti della Casa

Meatballs della Nana$12.00Blend of pork and beef meatballs gently braised in house-made tomato sauce, Pecorino Romano cheeseNot rated yet

Salsiccia alla Griglia$15.00Grilled Tony Fig's Italian sausage with lemonNot rated yet

Arancini al Burro$14.00Traditional teardrop-shaped fried saffron risotto combined with fresh mozzarella and prosciutto cotto, served with our house-made tomato sauceNot rated yet

Calamari Fritti$18.00Semolina-dusted fried calamari and zucchini strings with spicy Calabrian pepper tomato sauceNot rated yet

Mussels J. Matassini$20.00Twenty fresh Prince Edward Island mussels sautéed with Sicilian olive oil, sliced garlic, crushed red pepper and fresh parsley, simmered in a fresh grape tomato sauce. Served with focacciaNot rated yet

Gambino Mediterraneo$18.00Sauteed shrimp in "Gambino" prosecco sauce, garlic and citrusNot rated yet

Toasted Gnocchi$14.00Toasted fresh gnocchi stuffed with four cheeses, served with house-made tomato sauceNot rated yet

Millefoglie Melanzane$14.00Baked eggplant terrine layered with Pecorino Romano cheese, tomato sauceNot rated yet

Carciofi Ripieni "Reina"$16.00Roman artichoke sliced lengthwise and stuffed with Pecorino Romano cheese, lemon juice and "muddica": our Sicilian-style crispy breadcrumb blend seasoned with fresh garlic, herbs and olive oilNot rated yet

Burrata in Purgatorio$16.00Burrata cheese breaded with seasoned muddica breadcrumbs and fried, served in spicy tomato sauce with toast pointsNot rated yet

Insalate

Valenti's Burrata$16.00Burrata cheese, tomato, pickled red onion and arugula salad dressed with balsamic vinaigretteNot rated yet

Insalata di Cesare$8.00Romaine lettuce with classic Caesar dressing, garlic croutons, shaved pecorino RomanoNot rated yet

Pizza Parlor Giant Italian Salad$9.00Lettuce, celery, grape tomato, prosciutto cotto, provolone cheese and Sicilian olives, dressed simply in a savory Italian vinaigrette with parmesan cheese. Inspired by Tampa's legendary Pizza Parlor, an old-school favorite known for its towering saladsNot rated yet

Pizza

Margherita$16.00Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, extra-virgin olive oilNot rated yet

Pizza Vegetariana$16.00Vegetarian pizza with mushrooms, eggplant, spinach, mozzarella, tomato sauce, grated pecorinoNot rated yet

Sicilian Hot Honey$18.00Soppressata, ricotta, mozzarella, Calabrese cherry pepper, hot honey drizzleNot rated yet

Pizza Suprema$20.00House-made meatballs, crumbled sausage, mushroom, peppers, onions, mozzarella, tomato sauceNot rated yet

La Soppressata$18.00Famous flavors of mozzarella, spicy tomato sauce and thinly-sliced meat. Centuries before pepperoni, there was soppressata. This bold, coarsely ground salami is a staple of Sicilian cuisineNot rated yet

Contorni (Sides)

Broccolini$9.00Broccolini sautéed in extra-virgin olive oil, sliced garlic, pinch of red pepperNot rated yet

Imported Maccheroni Al Pomodoro$7.00Sicilian casarecce maccheroni with house-made tomato sauce, grated Pecorino Romano cheeseNot rated yet

Patate Saltati$7.00Sautéed baby Yukon Gold potato halves with Sicilian herbs and garlicNot rated yet

Sauté Spinaci$9.00Fresh sautéed spinach, extra-virgin olive oil, fresh garlicNot rated yet

Caponata$8.00Sicilian classic eggplant tossed with roasted garlic, celery, tomatoes, olives, capers, pine nuts, raisins, red onions, Sicilian spicesNot rated yet

Maccheroni

Pasta Bolognese$22.00Your choice of spaghetti or casarecce maccheroni with Bolognese blend of pork and beef, plum tomatoes, garlic, celery and carrots, with tomato sauce, Pecorino Romano cheeseNot rated yet

Spaghetti Nana Maria$26.00Meatball, pork shoulder and Italian sausage, hard-boiled egg, just like Nana Maria used to make, with tomato sauce, Pecorino RomanoNot rated yet

Spaghetti con Polpette$20.00"Spaghetti with meatballs" blend of beef and pork, gently braised in rich succo, with Pecorino RomanoNot rated yet

Casarecce "Rinaldi"$22.00Imported Sicilian casarecce pasta tossed with sautéed crumbled sausage, peas, garlic and crushed red pepper in a light cream sauceNot rated yet

Lasagna$22.00Baked layers of fresh pasta, garlic ricotta, mozzarella and Pecorino Romano cheese, mix of Italian sausage and Bolognese meat, with tomato sauceNot rated yet

Zappone's Linguine con Vongole$28.00Littleneck clams sautéed with garlic, crushed red pepper, fresh parsley, simmered in a white wine tomato sauce, hint of butter and Sicilian extra-virgin olive oilNot rated yet

Linguine Frutti di Mare "Buster Agliano"$40.00The ultimate linguine Frutti di Mare, with lobster, littleneck clams, mussels, squid and shrimp with fresh garlic, splash of white wine, simmered in a spicy red sauceNot rated yet

Spaghetti al Nero$36.00Black-ink spaghetti, sautéed calamari, white wine, cherry tomato sauce, garlic, shallots, Sicilian olives, spicy Calabrian peppers, fried breadcrumbs, lemonNot rated yet

Pasta alla Norma$20.00Sicily's most popular pasta dish. Casarecce maccheroni, fried eggplant, house-made tomato sauce, garlic, grated ricotta salata cheeseNot rated yet

Ravioli di Ricotta$22.00Ravioli stuffed with ricotta and pesto, tossed in tomato sauce with a sprinkle of Pecorino Romano cheeseNot rated yet

Gnocchi alle Verdure$22.00Fresh potato gnocchi tossed with cremini mushrooms, broccolini, baby spinach, peas, garlic and shallots in a light cream sauce with Pecorino Romano cheeseNot rated yet

Piatti della Tradizione (Traditional Plates)

Pollo Parmigiana "Scaglione"$25.00Dusted in flour, seared and baked the Sicilian way. Boneless chicken breasts, house-made tomato sauce, mozzarella, grated Parmesan and fresh basil. Served with a side of maccheroni pasta pomodoroNot rated yet

Pollo Marsala$28.00Boneless chicken breasts scaloppine sautéed in Marsala wine, garlic and cremini mushrooms with sautéed baby potatoesNot rated yet

Pork Chop Grigliato$22.008 oz. Compart Duroc pork chop chargrilled and glazed with fruit mostarda, vincotto balsamic reduction, served with sautéed baby potatoes, broccolini. One or two pork chopsNot rated yet

Veal Scaloppine Milanesa$28.00An Ybor City favorite, enjoyed at lunch and dinner tables by generations of Sicilian dairy-farming families. A thin slice of veal, dipped in egg and breadcrumbs with seasonings, grilled and smothered with sauce of tomatoes, onions and green peppers and served with sautéed baby potatoesNot rated yet

Veal Scaloppine Marsala "Trafficante"$28.00Lightly-breaded, pan-fried veal scaloppine with Marsala sauce, cremini mushrooms, sautéed baby potatoes, broccoliniNot rated yet

Filet Mignon$52.008 oz. chargrilled choice filet mignon rubbed with Sicilian extra-virgin olive oil, with side of broccolini, pecorino potatoes, lemon garlic butterNot rated yet

N.Y. Strip alla Griglia$52.0014 oz. USDA choice boneless New York strip steak brushed with garlic butter and served with sautéed baby potatoes, broccoliniNot rated yet

Merluzzo al Pesto Siciliano$32.00Wild-caught merluzzo, a mild and slightly sweet fish with tender, meaty white flakes, seared on the flat-top grill and topped with our house-made pesto Sicliano. Served with our Aglio e Olio pasta tossed with spinachNot rated yet

Sea Bass Grigliata$40.00Chargrilled Mediterranean sea bass marinated in extra-virgin olive oil and herbs. Served with broccolini and grilled lemonNot rated yet

Grouper al Limone$40.00Fresh Gulf of Mexico grouper sautéed in a lemon butter sauce with capers and white wine. Served with broccoliniNot rated yet

Swordfish "Messina"$28.00Swordfish fillet topped with tender tomatoes, onions, capers and olives – the classic preparation in Messina, Sicily. Served with broccoliniNot rated yet

Dolci (Desserts)

Cannoli di Ricotta$12.00Cannoli with Sicilian ricotta and chocolate chips, candied citrus, pistachioNot rated yet

Tiramisu$12.00Coffee-dipped ladyfingers, rum and mascarpone cream, dark cocoa dustNot rated yet

Torta al Limone$12.00Vanilla cake layered with lemon mascarpone and limoncello syrupNot rated yet

Affogato al Caffe$10.00Stracciatella gelato "drowned" in cold espresso shot, whipped cream, Frangelico liquor, toasted almonds, chocolate chipsNot rated yet

Gelato$9.00Assorted Sicilian gelati, flavors: dark cioccolato, vanilla, Sicilian pistachio, stracciatellaNot rated yet

Lunch Only

Panino Siciliano$16.00Prosciutto, mortadella, ham, sopressata, provolone, fresh tomato, Calabrian peppers, olives and vinaigrette dressing on muffaletta bread. Served with crispy potato chips.Not rated yet

Panino Parmigiana$18.00Breast of chicken sautéed with garlic, extra-virgin olive oil, house-made tomato sauce, and mozzarella on Cuban bread. Served with crispy potato chips.Not rated yet

Casa's Italian Steak Sandwich$18.00Shaved rib-eye sautéed with green peppers and onions, tossed with chopped romaine lettuce, diced tomatoes and lemon vinaigrette on a Cuban bread roll. Served with crispy potato chips.Not rated yet

Cartocciata Meatballs$16.00Traditional Sicilian street food, a handheld "bagful" similar to a calzone, brushed with garlic butter and stuffed with deliciousness. Pork and beef blend meatballs braised in house-made tomato sauce, sprinkled with Pecorino Romano cheese and basil. Served with crispy potato chips.Not rated yet

Linguine with Shrimp "Felicione"$22.00Shrimp sautéed and simmered in white wine, fresh grape tomato sauce, shallots, garlic, spicy crushed red pepperNot rated yet

Drinks

Prendiamo un Caffè!

Caffè Corretto with a Taste of Sambuca$6.00Not rated yet

Espresso$3.00Not rated yet

Espresso Doppio$5.00Not rated yet

Cappuccino$5.00Not rated yet

Macchiato$4.00Not rated yet