Best key lime pie in Sarasota

36 places serve it. Ranked by dish ratings (verified diners count most), then by the place’s overall rating.

1. 1Figaro BistroKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.95
2. 2Caribbean Pie CompanyClassic Key Lime Pie · For more than 35 years, our signature Key Lime Pie has been a Sarasota favorite. Silky smooth, refreshingly tart, and nestled in a golden graham cracker crust, every pie is handcrafted using the same beloved recipe that earned us the 2023 People's Choice Award for Best Pie in Sarasota. It's not just dessert—it's a taste of Florida tradition.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
3. 3Shakespeare's Craft Beer and Gastro PubKey Lime Pie · Topped with whipped cream or custard.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$6.75
4. 4Claytons Cafe and grilleClayton's Key Lime Pie · Florida key lime pie with a graham cracker crust, topped with fresh berries and whipped cream.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
5. 5The Parrot Patio Bar & GrillKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
6. 6Duffy's Sports GrillKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$9.99
7. 7Libby'sKey Lime Pie · Scratch-made key lime pie, pecan graham cracker crust, nellie & joe's® key lime juice, fresh whipped creamDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$10.00
8. 8Yoder‘s RestaurantFlorida Key Lime Pie · Traditional in graham crust. Served by the slice. À la mode add 2.00.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$7.95
9. 9LilaKey Lime Pie · Coconut cream, fresh limeDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$16.00
10. 10Mattison's City GrilleKEY LIME PIE · raspberry coulis, crème Chantilly, lime zest, fresh berriesDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$10.00
11. 11Owen's Fish CampKey Lime Pie · W/ Fresh Whipped Cream 11.99Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$11.99
12. 12Phillippi Creek Oyster BarKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.95
13. 13PinchersSIGNATURE KEY LIME PIE · Served slightly frozen.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
14. 14ColumbiaKey Lime Pie · Graham cracker crust, filling made from pasteurized egg yolks, condensed milk and "Nellie & Joe's" Key lime juice.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
15. 15Chef Rolf's New Florida Kitchen IncTraditional Key Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
16. 16Latin QuartersKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
17. 17New Pass Grill & Bait ShopKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$7.00
18. 18Caribbean Pie CompanyClassic Key Lime Pie · For more than 35 years, our signature Key Lime Pie has been a Sarasota favorite. Silky smooth, refreshingly tart, and nestled in a golden graham cracker crust, every pie is handcrafted using the same beloved recipe that earned us the 2023 People's Choice Award for Best Pie in Sarasota. It's not just dessert—it's a taste of Florida tradition.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
19. 19Daiquiri Deck St. ArmandsKEY LIME PIE COCKTAIL · A Florida favorite! Featuring Broken Plank Coconut Rum, Vanilla Vodka, Coconut Rum Cream, lime juice and a touch of coconut.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
20. 20Ocean Prime SarasotaKey Lime Pie · Graham Cracker Crust, Whipped CreamDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$16.00
21. 21Daiquiri Deck South Siesta KeyKEY LIME PIE COCKTAIL · A Florida favorite! Featuring Broken Plank Coconut Rum, Vanilla Vodka, Coconut Rum Cream. lime juice and a touch of coconut.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
22. 22Chart HouseKey Lime Pie · creamy Florida Key Lime custard, graham cracker crust, whipped creamDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
23. 23YogurtologyKey West Key Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
24. 24Daiquiri DeckKEY LIME PIE COCKTAIL · A Florida favorite! Featuring Broken Plank Coconut Rum, Vanilla Vodka, Coconut Rum Cream. lime juice and a touch of coconut.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$12.00
25. 25Brick’s Smoked MeatsKEY LIME PIE · Graham cracker crumb crust, cinnamon, brown sugar, tart key lime fillingDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$2.95
26. 26The Lucky PelicanKey Lime Pie · Graham cracker crust, whipped cream, powdered sugar.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$9.50
27. 27Owen's Fish CampKey Lime Pie · A refreshing Florida classic made with tangy key lime filling in a gluten-free crust, finished with whipped cream for a bright, smooth, and refreshing dessert! Gluten FreeDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$11.99
28. 28Kacey's Seafood & MoreKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$7.95
29. 29TIKI BAR at Chef Rolfs NFKTraditional Key Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
30. 30P.F. Chang'sKey Lime Pie · Sweet & tangy key lime mousse, cookie crumb crust, whipped cream, toasted coconut, vanilla sauceDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
31. 31Cha Cha CoconutsKey West Key Lime Pie · No meal would be complete without this Florida favorite, made with Key limes and a graham cracker crustDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
32. 32LQ On MainKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★
33. 33Main Bar Sandwich ShopKey Lime Pie · Tart and creamy pie filled with a burst of citrus flavor.Dish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$4.75
34. 34Tamiami TapKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.00
35. 35Gilligans Island Bar & GrillKey Lime PieDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$8.99
36. 36Charlie's Steak & HoagieMEGA KEY LIME PIE · Real Key Lime Juice, Macadamia Nut Crust, Fresh Whipped CreamDish not rated yet · restaurant – ★$21.00