Photo by Los Muertos Crew on Pexels
Classic Key Lime Pie
For more than 35 years, our signature Key Lime Pie has been a Sarasota favorite. Silky smooth, refreshingly tart, and nestled in a golden graham cracker crust, every pie is handcrafted using the same beloved recipe that earned us the 2023 People's Choice Award for Best Pie in Sarasota. It's not just dessert—it's a taste of Florida tradition. · at Caribbean Pie Company
KitchenSpot summaryA classic key lime pie with a smooth, tart filling and a graham cracker crust.
tartcitrusysweet
Contains dairy, gluten. Based on the menu description, not checked by the restaurant. Tell the restaurant about any allergy before you order.
Written by KitchenSpot from the menu and public information, not a diner review. Ratings come only from diners.
Where to get it in Sarasota
Restaurants serving key lime pie, ranked by dish ratings, then restaurant ratings.
Figaro BistroKey Lime Pie$8.952Caribbean Pie CompanyClassic Key Lime Pie3Shakespeare's Craft Beer and Gastro PubKey Lime Pie$6.754Claytons Cafe and grilleClayton's Key Lime Pie$12.005The Parrot Patio Bar & GrillKey Lime Pie$8.006Duffy's Sports GrillKey Lime Pie$9.997Libby'sKey Lime Pie$10.008Yoder‘s RestaurantFlorida Key Lime Pie$7.959LilaKey Lime Pie$16.0010Mattison's City GrilleKEY LIME PIE$10.00What diners say
No one has rated this dish yet.