Strachan's Ice Cream & Desserts

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Nov 6, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

“Likely” diet labels: Based on the menu description, not checked by the restaurant. Tell the restaurant about any allergy before you order.

Gourmet

Carrot CakeAskCarrot cake batter ice cream with chunks of our award-winning carrot cakeNot rated yet

Reese's Peanut Butter CupAskPeanut butter with sweet and salty Reese's cupsNot rated yet

Rocky RoadAskCreamy Chocolate exploding with marshmallows and walnutsNot rated yet

Vanilla BrownieAskFresh baked brownie pieces hand folded into creamy vanillaNot rated yet

Rum RaisinAskRum soaked raisins poured into rich vanillaNot rated yet

Salted Chocolate CaramelAskThick gooey caramel folded into creamy vanilla with dark chocolate chunksNot rated yet

Orange PineappleAskOrange cream with chunks of tropical pineappleNot rated yet

Peanut Butter Cookie DoughAskPeanut Butter ice cream with cookie dough ball folded inNot rated yet

Peanut Butter Fudge SwirlAskPeanut Butter ice cream with thick rich chocolate fudge swirled inNot rated yet

PeppermintAsk50 pounds of crushed peppermints folded into exhilarating mint creamNot rated yet

Pistachio AlmondAskSubtle pistachio flavored cream filled with almond sliversNot rated yet

Pralines n' CreamAskCandy coated pralines and decadent ribbons of sweet caramel folded into creamy vanillaNot rated yet

Pumpkin CheesecakeAskPureed Pumpkin, warm spices, swirls of cream cheese icing and Chunks of New York CheesecakeNot rated yet

Cookie DoughAskBrown Sugar cream batter filled with yummy cookie dough chunksNot rated yet

Egg NogAskThick creamy eggnog and warm winter spicesNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Maple WalnutAskMaple Syrup blended into cream and loaded with WalnutsNot rated yet

Heath Bar CrunchAskToffee flavored cream packed with chunks of Heath Bar candyNot rated yet

JaMocha Almond ChipAskCoffee and chocolate cream come together with almond slivers and chocolate chipsNot rated yet

Cherry Wow-ZaAskCherry vanilla base, with candied maraschino cherries, huge walnuts and dark chocolate chunksNot rated yet

Almond JoyAskCoconut cream, real coconut shavings, almond slivers and dark chocolate chunksNot rated yet

BananaAsk30 pounds of real bananas and just right amount of sugarNot rated yet

Birthday CakeAskCake batter and butter cream mixed together and loaded with rainbow sprinklesNot rated yet

Black CherryAskBig Juicy dark cherries packed into dark cherry flavored creamNot rated yet

Butter PecanAskRight amount of Buttery and sweet loaded with pecan halvesNot rated yet

Cherry VanillaAskCherry juices blended with cream and filled with sweet maraschino cherriesNot rated yet

Blue JayAskSmooth vanilla with ribbons of decadent caramel, roasted salted nuts and cracker jacks- perfect for after the game!Not rated yet

ButterfingerAskPeanut butter flavored cream filled with chunks of Butterfinger candyNot rated yet

Red Velvet CakeAskRed velvet batter and cream cheese mixed into the cream with chunks of homemade red velvet cakeNot rated yet

Cookie MonsterAskSugar cookie batter blended with cream and packed with homemade chocolate chip cookies and oreosNot rated yet

Signature

VanillaAskCream and sugar made with finest Madagascar Bourbon VanillaNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

ChocolateAskRich, decadent dark chocolateNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

StrawberryAskSweet strawberries n' creamNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Key LimeAskTropical, twangy and refreshingNot rated yet

Black RaspberryAskVelvety smooth pureed black raspberries n' creamNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Orange CreamsicleAskOld fashioned orange soda and creamNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Mint Chocolate ChipAskRefreshing mint extract with chocolate chipsNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

ButterscotchAskThick, Creamy butterscotch blended with creamNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Caramel PopcornAskSweet, salty and creamy!Not rated yet

Chocolate OreoAskRich, dark chocolate with Oreos hand folded inNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

CinnamonAskWarm Cinnamon Spice!Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

CoconutAskCoconut milk and fresh coconut shavingsNot rated yet

CoffeeAskStrong brewed coffee, vanilla and cream!Not rated yet

Mint OreoAskRefreshing mint with Oreos hand folded inNot rated yet

Cookies n' CreamAskVanilla cream and Loads of crunch OreosNot rated yet

Coffee n' CookiesAskRich, strong coffee, cream and OreosNot rated yet

Purple CowAskFruity Grape from our purple cows! : )Not rated yet

SmurfAskTutti Fruitti blue cream with marshmallowsNot rated yet

Chocolate Chocolate ChunkAskRich, creamy chocolate with dark chocolate chunksNot rated yet

Soft Serves

Vanilla CustardAskGoes best smothered in our homemade warm Yummy Yummy SauceNot rated yet

Chocolate CustardAskNot rated yet

Fat Free Vanilla YogurtAskNot rated yet

Sorbets

Strawberry LemonadeAskCompletely dairy free and made with water and fruit juicesNot rated yetDairy-free

RaspberryAskCompletely dairy free and made with water and fruit juicesNot rated yetDairy-freeLikely Vegan

LemonAskCompletely dairy free and made with water and fruit juicesNot rated yetDairy-freeLikely Vegan

WatermelonAskCompletely dairy free and made with water and fruit juicesNot rated yetDairy-freeLikely Vegan

MangoAskCompletely dairy free and made with water and fruit juicesNot rated yetDairy-freeLikely Vegan

Sherbets

Rainbow SwirlAskNaturally low in fatNot rated yet

Orange CreamAskNaturally low in fatNot rated yet

RaspberryAskNaturally low in fatNot rated yet

Homemade Desserts

Mrs. Strachan's Carrot CakeAskThis melt in your mouth carrot cake has a flavor and consistency like nobody else's. Each hand mixed batch packs 14 cups of pecans and 5 pounds of freshly shredded local carrots. Each cake is smothered with our sweet and buttery special sauce when it is pulled hot from the oven. Our carrot cakes are then iced with our sweet cream cheese icing made from scratch daily. Our 8" double layer carrot…Not rated yet

Reese's Peanut Butter PieAskServed in a graham cracker shell that is filled with our light and fluffy sweet peanut buttery concoction 3 inches high! The top is coated with real crushed pieces of Reese's peanut butter cups, then drizzled with our rich, thick fudge.Not rated yet

Key Lime PieAskOur unique key lime pie has a fun, tropical tangy flavor. Made with real juice from key limes from right here in Florida. Topped generously with our sweet whipped meringue, toasted to caramelized perfection. Also served dipped in chocolate on a portable hand-held stick.Not rated yet

Ice Cream CakesAskWhether you're looking for a custom ice cream cake made with your favorite Strachan's homemade ice cream flavor or a ready-to-go ice cream cake, we have it!Not rated yet