Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Nov 5, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

“Likely” diet labels: Based on the menu description, not checked by the restaurant. Tell the restaurant about any allergy before you order.

Food

Homemade Selections

VanillaAskNot rated yet

ChocolateAskNot rated yet

StrawberryAskNot rated yet

CoffeeAskNot rated yet

Butter PecanAskNot rated yet

Cotton CandyAskNot rated yet

Mint Chocolate ChipAskNot rated yet

Chocolate Lover'sAskNot rated yet

SupermanAskNot rated yet

Birthday CakeAskNot rated yet

Salted CaramelAskNot rated yet

Blueberry CobblerAskNot rated yet

Black RaspberryAskNot rated yet

Cupid's Love PotionAskNot rated yet

Death by Peanut ButterAskNot rated yet

Nutty Cup of JoeAskNot rated yet

PeppermintAskNot rated yet

Beach BumAskNot rated yet

Rum RaisinAskNot rated yet

Key Lime PieAskNot rated yet

Trash CanAskNot rated yet

Royal TurtleAskNot rated yet

Soft Ice Cream

VanillaAskNot rated yet

Almond MilkAskNot rated yetVeganDairy-free

Dole WhipAskVegan & Dairy FreeNot rated yetVeganDairy-free

Sundae Specials

Mississippi Mud PieAskWarm Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Chocolate Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, topped with Whipped Cream. A Chocolate Lover's Delight!Not rated yet

Chocolate Chip Cookie SurpriseAskWarm Chocolate Chip Cookie served with your choice of Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, topped with Whipped CreamNot rated yet

Wet NutsAskYour choice of Ice Cream, smothered in a Maple Walnut topping, topped with Whipped Cream, sprinkled with Nuts. Old Fashioned Goodness!Not rated yet

Sandy's TurtlesAskVanilla Ice Cream covered with Hot Carmel and Hot Fudge, Pecans, topped with Whipped Cream. Great Flavor!Not rated yet

Monkey MadnessAskBanana lined bowl, vanilla bean ice cream, covered with peanut butter sauce, creamy whipped cream and chopped peanuts.Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Dusty RoadsAskYour choice of ice cream covered in hot fudge with a dusting of malt powder, topped with creamy whipped cream. An old-time favorite!Not rated yet

Warm Brownie SundaeAskMint Chip Ice Cream, Warm Brownies, Hot Fudge, Whip Cream. Delicious!Not rated yet

Chocolate Coconut SundaeAskChocolate Ice Cream, Hot Caramel, Topped with Coconut and Whip Cream. Delicious crunchy treat!Not rated yet

Island Favorites

George WashingtonAskWarm fudge brownie covered with Black Cherry Ice Cream, smothered in hot fudge, topped with creamy whipped cream and sprinkles.Not rated yet

The Peanut Butter CupAskPeanut Butter Ice Cream with mini peanut butter cups, topped with hot fudge, whipped cream and more peanut butter. For Peanut Butter Lovers! Bursting with flavor!Not rated yet

GrasshopperAskMint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream loaded with chocolate flakes, served over warm chocolate chip cookies, smothered with hot fudge, creamy whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles.Not rated yet

Drinks

Milkshakes & Malts

Chocolate BananaAskMade with premium ingredients and mixed into a creamy drink.Not rated yet

Peanut Butter BananaAskMade with premium ingredients and mixed into a creamy drink.Not rated yet

Peanut ButterAskMade With Real Peanut ButterNot rated yet

Cookies & CreamAskMade with premium ingredients and mixed into a creamy drink.Not rated yet

Pumpkin PieAskIn SeasonNot rated yet

Root BeerAskMade with premium ingredients and mixed into a creamy drink.Not rated yet

Birthday CakeAskMade with premium ingredients and mixed into a creamy drink.Not rated yet

Coffee Frappés

French VanillaAskVanilla Ice Cream and Coffee, topped with Whipped CreamNot rated yet

Kappa Kappa CaféAskCoffee Ice Cream, Coffee, topped with Whipped CreamNot rated yet