KitchenSpot
Search
See the best dishes near you?
← Sarasota County restaurants

Stottlemyer's Smokehouse

No reviews yet

Barbecue19 East Rd, Sarasota

Call Directions Website

Own or manage Stottlemyer's Smokehouse? Claim this listing free

MenuReviews · 0Photos · 1Hours & info

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 26, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks.

“Likely” diet labels: Based on the menu description, not checked by the restaurant. Tell the restaurant about any allergy before you order.

Appetizers

Stottlemyer’s Famous CornbreadStottlemyer’s Famous Cornbread$8.994 Pieces of our homemade cornbread served with butterNot rated yet
Bacon-Wrapped JalapeñosBacon-Wrapped Jalapeños$12.99Served with a buffalo cream cheese fillingNot rated yet
Crab RangoonsCrab Rangoons$10.99Homemade rangoons stuffed with a creamy crab filling and served with sweet Thai chili sauceNot rated yet
Smokehouse MeatballsSmokehouse Meatballs$12.99Made from a blend of beef, veal, and pork and topped with Romano and Fontina cheeseNot rated yet
BBQ NachosBBQ Nachos$14.99Housemade chips topped with baked beans, cheddar cheese sauce, diced tomatoes, pickled jalapeños, and coleslaw. Choice of pulled pork or smoked chicken, topped with our signature sweet or spicy BBQ sauceNot rated yet
Cheese NachosCheese Nachos$9.99Housemade chips topped with cheddar cheese sauce, diced tomatoes, and green onionsNot rated yet
Chicken WingsChicken Wings$13.99Choice of smoked, naked, or breaded wings tossed with buffalo sauce, Korean BBQ sauce, Nashville hot sauce, hot honey, or our homemade BBQ sauce (sweet or spicy)Not rated yet
Loaded French FriesLoaded French Fries$11.99Crispy fries topped with cheddar cheese sauce, diced bacon, and green onionsNot rated yet
Chili Cheese FriesChili Cheese Fries$14.99Housemade brisket chili on a bed of crispy fries topped with shredded cheddar cheese, sour cream, and green onionsNot rated yet
Comfort FriesComfort Fries$6.99Crispy fries topped with our housemade brown gravyNot rated yet
Mozzarella SticksMozzarella Sticks$10.99Mozzarella cheese fried, served with marinara dipping sauceNot rated yet
Fried OkraFried Okra$10.99Okra fried and served with ranch dipping sauceNot rated yet
Shrimp BitesShrimp Bites$11.99White shrimp pieces fried and served with chipotle mayo dipping sauceNot rated yet
Smoked Fish DipSmoked Fish Dip$14.99White fish mixed with cream cheese and a touch of spice. Served with veggies and saltine crackersNot rated yet

Sandwiches

Pulled PorkPulled Pork$15.99Topped with our signature sweet or spicy BBQ & coleslaw. Served on a brioche bunNot rated yet
Sliced BrisketSliced Brisket$17.99Topped with our signature sweet or spicy BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese, and fried onion rings. Served on a brioche bunNot rated yet
GrouperGrouper$20.99Fried, blackened, or grilled with a side of tartar sauce. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, & pickle. Served on a brioche bunNot rated yet
Famous Fried ChickenFamous Fried Chicken$15.99Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, & pickles on a brioche bun. Served Nashville style, hot honey, or nakedNot rated yet
French DipFrench Dip$18.99Shaved prime rib served with mushrooms, sautéed onions, and topped with Swiss cheese. Served on a toasted hoagie with au jus sauceNot rated yet
BurgerBurger$14.99Angus beef served with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on a toasted brioche bunNot rated yet
Shrimp Po’boyShrimp Po’boy$16.99Lightly breaded shrimp pieces fried golden brown. Served on a toasted hoagie roll with sliced tomato, shredded lettuce, and chipotle mayoNot rated yet
Chicken PhillyChicken Philly$15.99Pulled smoked chicken, sautéed mushrooms, and onions, topped with provolone cheese. Served on a toasted hoagie bunNot rated yet

Salads & Soups

Steve's Garden SaladSteve's Garden Salad$7.99Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, red pepper, croutons, and cheddar cheeseNot rated yet
Stott's Cobb SaladStott's Cobb Salad$17.99Pulled smoked chicken, diced bacon, cucumber, grape tomato, kalamata olive, red onion, roasted corn, sliced pepperoncini, and gorgonzola on a bed of mixed greensNot rated yet
Greek SaladGreek Salad$9.99Romaine, tomato, cucumber, onion, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, and feta cheeseNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian
Caesar SaladCaesar Salad$7.99Chopped romaine tossed in a creamy Caesar dressing, topped with croutons and grated parmesanNot rated yet
New England Clam ChowderNew England Clam Chowder$11.99Made daily by our chef with bacon, celery, garlic, parsley, chopped quahog clams, and diced potato in a creamy base. Served in a 16 oz mug with our famous cornbreadNot rated yet
Smoked Brisket ChiliSmoked Brisket Chili$12.99Made daily by our chef with onion, celery, red pepper, kidney beans, chipotle pepper, and special house seasoning in a tomato base. Served in a 16 oz mug with our famous cornbreadNot rated yet
DressingsDressingsRanch, blue cheese, balsamic vinaigrette, raspberry vinaigrette, roasted tomato vinaigrette, honey mustardNot rated yet

Fried Chicken

2 Piece White (breast & wing)2 Piece White (breast & wing)$14.99NoneNot rated yet
3 Piece White (2 breasts & wing)3 Piece White (2 breasts & wing)$17.99NoneNot rated yet
2 Piece Dark (thigh & leg)2 Piece Dark (thigh & leg)$12.99NoneNot rated yet
3 Piece Dark (2 thighs & leg)3 Piece Dark (2 thighs & leg)$16.99NoneNot rated yet
Chicken TendersChicken Tenders$12.99NoneNot rated yet

Authentic BBQ

Beef BrisketBeef Brisket$24.99Slow-cooked overnight and sliced to orderNot rated yet
Baby Back RibsBaby Back Ribs$22.99Smoked hot and fast dailyNot rated yet
Smokin' Pulled PorkSmokin' Pulled Pork$20.99Slow-smoked pork shredded and seasoned with our house rubNot rated yet
Smoked ChickenSmoked Chicken$18.99Tender, smoked chicken that falls off the boneNot rated yet
East Road Sampler$32.99Half rack of baby back ribs, 6 oz of sliced brisket, and a choice of light or dark smoked chickenNot rated yet
Mini Sampler$25.99Quarter rack of baby back ribs, 4 oz sliced brisket, and choice of light or dark smoked chickenNot rated yet
Cornbread SmokestackCornbread Smokestack$20.99Our famous cornbread is toasted with butter and topped with your choice of smoked chicken, pulled pork, or brisket and coleslaw. Topped with your choice of our signature sweet or spicy BBQ sauceNot rated yet
Mac AttackMac Attack$14.99A bowl of our housemade mac & cheese topped with cheese sauce, onion rings, and our signature sweet or spicy BBQ sauce. Your choice of chicken, pork, or sautéed broccoliNot rated yet

Fish

Daily Fish SpecialDaily Fish SpecialAsk your server what the chef has prepared for you todayNot rated yet
Fried HaddockFried Haddock$20.99North Atlantic haddock fillet lightly dusted with cornmeal and served with lemon and tartar sauceNot rated yet
Fried ShrimpFried Shrimp$16.99Lightly breaded white shrimp fried golden brown and served with chipotle mayoNot rated yet

Kids

Mac and CheeseMac and Cheese$8.99NoneNot rated yet
Pulled Pork SandwichPulled Pork Sandwich$9.99NoneNot rated yet
8” Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza8” Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza$8.99NoneNot rated yet
Chicken TendersChicken Tenders$11.99NoneNot rated yet

Dessert

Peanut Butter PiePeanut Butter Pie$8.99NoneNot rated yet
Key Lime PieKey Lime Pie$8.99NoneNot rated yet

Specialty Pizzas

Smokehouse Meat loversSmokehouse Meat lovers$22.99Smoked chicken, pulled pork, brisket, and smoked spicy Italian sausageNot rated yet
Traditional Meat LoversTraditional Meat Lovers$21.99Pepperoni, crumbled sausage, ham, and baconNot rated yet
Loaded Smokehouse$23.99Pulled chicken, pork, brisket, hot Italian sausage, sautéed mushrooms, roasted red pepper, caramelized onion, and sliced black oliveNot rated yet
Italiano$21.99Pepperoni, crumbled sausage, sautéed mushrooms, roasted red pepper, caramelized onion, and sliced black olivesNot rated yet
BBQ$20.99BBQ sauce base, mozzarella cheese, caramelized onion, smoked chicken or brisket, topped with our signature sweet BBQ sauceNot rated yet
White PizzaWhite Pizza$21.99Garlic cream sauce base, mozzarella cheese, parmesan cheese, smoked chicken, spinach, and baconNot rated yet
MargheritaMargherita$20.99Garlic and olive oil sauce base, roasted balsamic tomato, and fresh mozzarella cheese finished with basil oil and balsamic glazeNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian
Buffalo ChickenBuffalo Chicken$19.99Buffalo sauce base, shredded mozzarella cheese, gorgonzola cheese, and smoked chickenNot rated yet
Bacon Chicken RanchBacon Chicken Ranch$20.99Ranch dressing base, shredded mozzarella cheese, diced bacon, and smoked chickenNot rated yet
HawaiianHawaiian$17.99Diced ham and pineappleNot rated yet
Hot Roni$17.99Pepperoni and hot honeyNot rated yet
VegetarianVegetarian$17.99Broccoli, spinach, puréed garlic, and mozzarella cheeseNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Build Your Own Pizza

Meats Toppings$2.99Brisket, smoked chicken, pork, bacon, ham, pepperoni, crumbled sausage, hot Italian sausageNot rated yet
Veggies Toppings$1.50Banana pepper, roasted mushroom, red pepper, caramelized onion, black olive, spinach, balsamic roasted tomato, pineapple, pickled jalapeñoNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian
Flavor Bombs Toppings$1.50Balsamic glaze, puréed garlic, hot honey, buffalo sauce, basil oil, ranch dressingNot rated yet