KitchenSpot
Search
See the best dishes near you?
← Sarasota restaurants

Michelle’s Brown Bag Cafe

No reviews yet

Sandwich · American · Breakfast · Lunch · Brunch · BagelClosed now · opens Wed 9 AM630 South Orange Avenue, Sarasota

Call Directions Website

Own or manage Michelle’s Brown Bag Cafe? Claim this listing free

MenuReviews · 0Photos · 0Hours & info

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 10, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks.

Gourmet Sandwiches

The Manatee$13.00Greens, cucumber, tomato, sprouts, pickled red onion, mushrooms, hummusNot rated yet
Bird Key$15.00Homemade chicken salad, sliced apple, baby greens, tomato, sprouts, gorgonzolaNot rated yet
Anna MariaAnna Maria$16.00Locally smoked salmon, baby greens, sweet red onion, sprouts, cucumber, herbed goat cheese, pesto aioliNot rated yet
De Soto$14.00Boar's Head turkey, homemade herbed stuffing, baby greens, cranberry relish, pesto aioliNot rated yet
Harbor MasterMaine lobster salad with fresh dill mayo, cucumber, capers, baby greens, tomatoNot rated yet
Longboat Brie$15.00Honey ham, brie, baby greens, cucumber, tomato, homemade mango chutney, pesto aioliNot rated yet
Bradenturkey$14.00Boar's Head turkey, bacon, cheddar, baby greens, tomato, cucumber, pesto aioliNot rated yet
Islander$15.00Sliced roast beef, herbed goat cheese, baby greens, tomato, cucumber, sweet red onion, pesto aioliNot rated yet
Port Rivo$14.00Marinated portobello, fresh mozzarella, baby greens, tomato, sprouts, pesto aioliNot rated yet
Bayfront TunaBayfront Tuna$15.00Homemade albacore tuna salad, baby spinach, tomato, sprouts, cucumber, provoloneNot rated yet
Ca' D' Zan$16.00Honey ham, roast beef, swiss, smoked bacon, greens, tomato, red onion, banana peppers, dijon, pesto mayoNot rated yet

Grilled Paninis

#1 Apple & White Cheddar#1 Apple & White Cheddar$12.00Sliced green apple, aged white cheddar & fresh spinachNot rated yet
#2 Mushroom & Swiss#2 Mushroom & Swiss$13.00Fresh mushroom, red onion, baby spinach, sprouts & swissNot rated yet
#3 Ham & 3-Cheese#3 Ham & 3-Cheese$13.00Boar's Head ham & three cheesesNot rated yet
#4 Caprese & Bacon#4 Caprese & Bacon$14.00Tomato, fresh mozzarella, smoked bacon & basilNot rated yet
#5 Turkey & Brie#5 Turkey & Brie$14.00Boar's Head turkey & brie with mango chutneyNot rated yet
#6 Tuna & Provolone#6 Tuna & Provolone$15.00Albacore tuna, provolone & baby spinachNot rated yet
#7 Smoked Salmon#7 Smoked Salmon$16.00Locally smoked salmon, goat cheese & red onionNot rated yet

Field of Greens

Farmer's Market$13.00Baby greens, tomato, mushrooms, cucumber, sweet pickled red onion & warm pitaNot rated yet
Selby Gardens$15.00Fresh spinach, smoked bacon, cucumber, pickled red onion, mushrooms, gorgonzola & pitaNot rated yet
Chef LidoChef Lido$15.00Honey ham, turkey, provolone, baby greens, tomato, cucumber, mushrooms, sprouts & warm pitaNot rated yet
The Ringling$14.00Baby spinach, sliced green apple, brie, cucumber, mushrooms & warm pitaNot rated yet
Red, White & GreensRed, White & Greens$14.00Tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, baby greens, balsamic vinaigrette & pitaNot rated yet

Favorites & More

Turkey Groovin' ReubenTurkey Groovin' Reuben$14.00Swiss, homemade Thousand Island & sauerkraut on ryeNot rated yet
Ahi Tuna SaladAhi Tuna Salad$16.00Seared sesame ahi, cucumber, crispy wontons, asparagus & tomato over greens, ginger sesame vinaigretteNot rated yet
SRQPD PaniniSRQPD Panini$15.00Roast beef, swiss, mushrooms, red onion, spinach & tomato with pesto aioli on focacciaNot rated yet
Siesta Fiesta$15.00Seasoned chicken, cheddar, black olives, avocado, salsa & sour cream over tortilla chips & greensNot rated yet

Half in the Bag

The Half & HalfThe Half & HalfHalf of any cold sandwich on 9-grain wheat or pumpernickel rye, plus your choice of the daily homemade soup or a half Farmer's Market saladNot rated yet
Homemade SoupsHomemade SoupsMade fresh daily — ask what's on todayNot rated yet

Add a Large Scoop

Homemade Chicken Salad$5.00

Albacore Tuna Salad$6.00

Marinated Portobello Mushroom$4.00

Smoked Salmon$8.00

Homemade Hummus$4.00

Breakfast — Served All Day

Fresh Berry ParfaitFresh Berry Parfait$11.00Crunchy granola, low-fat vanilla yogurt & fresh berriesNot rated yet
Bagel with Cream CheeseBagel with Cream Cheese$5.00Plain, wheat or everything · add tomato & onion +$2Not rated yet
Smoked Salmon BagelSmoked Salmon Bagel$16.00Smoked salmon, capers & onionNot rated yet
Peanut Butter & Apple BagelPeanut Butter & Apple Bagel$8.00With sliced green appleNot rated yet
Hummus BagelHummus Bagel$10.00Hummus, sprouts & tomatoNot rated yet

Egg Sandwiches

Egg, tomato, fresh mozzarella & basilEgg, tomato, fresh mozzarella & basilNot rated yet
Egg, ham, swiss, spinach & mushroomEgg, ham, swiss, spinach & mushroomNot rated yet
Egg, bacon, tomato & white cheddarEgg, bacon, tomato & white cheddarNot rated yet
Egg, goat cheese, roasted reds & spinachEgg, goat cheese, roasted reds & spinachNot rated yet
Egg, chorizo sausage & provoloneEgg, chorizo sausage & provoloneNot rated yet
Egg, avocado, crispy bacon & brieEgg, avocado, crispy bacon & brieNot rated yet
Egg, smoked salmon, dill cream cheese & capersEgg, smoked salmon, dill cream cheese & capersNot rated yet