Sarasota Bakehouse

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 25, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

Seasonal

Pumpkin Spice Cupcake$5.00Pumpkin spice cupcake topped with your choice of: Pumpkin flavored cream cheese frosting, Pumpkin flavored buttercream frosting (available vegan), or Chocolate Buttercream frosting (available vegan). All topped with crushed graham cracker.Not rated yet

Custom Cakes

NY Style Cheesecake$55.00A velvety and smooth NY style cheesecake with a thin layer of graham cracker crust. Available plain or add cherry, blueberry, or raspberry topping. Available only in a 9" cake which serves 10-12 people.Not rated yet

Cupcakes

Blueberry Lemon$4.00Yellow cake, blueberry filling, vanilla & lemon frostingNot rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Caramel Latte$4.00Chocolate cake, caramel & espresso frosting, chocolate and caramel drizzle with an espresso bean topper.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Carrot Cake$5.00Carrot cake baked with pineapple and pecans, cream cheese frosting w/orange sugar.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Cherry Cheesecake$4.00Chocolate cake, cherry pie filling, cream cheese frosting, and graham cracker.Not rated yetGluten-free

Chocolate Lovers$5.00Chocolate cake, chocolate frosting, brownie topper & chocolate drizzle. Gluten-free and vegan versions have no brownie; they get extra chocolate drizzle and chocolate sprinkles.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Classic Chocolate$4.00Chocolate cake, vanilla frosting, chocolate sprinklesNot rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Classic Vanilla$4.00Yellow cake, vanilla or chocolate frosting, rainbow sprinklesNot rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Cookies & Cream$4.00Chocolate cake, vanilla frosting, Oreos on top and drizzled with chocolate and marshmallow sauce.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Cotton Candy$4.00Chocolate or yellow cake topped with a swirled cotton candy flavored icing.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Florida Sunshine$5.00Vanilla cupcake filled with our own orange cream filling and topped off with vanilla and orange flavored icing and candied orange peel.Not rated yet

German Chocolate$5.00Chocolate cake, coconut/pecan filling, chocolate frosting, and drizzled with chocolate sauce.Not rated yet

Halloween "Fright" or "Boo" Bites 4-pack$22.00Choose 2 fun 4-packs: "Fright Bites" (fangs, skulls, coffins, poisonous potions) or "Boo Bites" (ghosts, pumpkins, witch hats, candy corn). Each is an assorted 4-pack (2 vanilla; 2 chocolate). Vegan option will vary slightly.Not rated yet

Heath Toffee$4.00Chocolate cake, vanilla frosting, heath toffee w/chocolate & caramel drizzleNot rated yetGluten-free

Holy Cannoli Cupcake$5.00Vanilla cake adorned with a mini cannoli (ricotta filling) and topped with vanilla buttercream frosting, mini chocolate chips, and chocolate drizzle. Gluten-free version has no cannoli shell.Not rated yetGluten-free

Key Lime$5.00Yellow cake, our signature Key Lime Filling, Cream Cheese frosting, and dusted with Green Sugar.Not rated yetGluten-free

Neopolitan$4.00Chocolate or yellow cake w/chocolate, vanilla, & strawberry frosting and topped with rainbow sprinkles.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Nutella$5.00Yellow cake, Nutella filling, our signature Nutella cream cheese frosting, and topped with a Ferrero Rocher chocolate and chocolate drizzle. Gluten-free version has crushed hazelnuts instead of Ferrero Rocher.Not rated yetGluten-free

Peanut Butter$4.00Chocolate cake, our signature peanut butter filling, chocolate frosting, Reese's chips on top and drizzled with chocolate sauce.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Pistachio$5.00Vanilla cake filled with a pistachio cream filling, pistachio flavored frosting, and topped with toasted pistachio's. Vegan option will NOT have cream filling.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Pretzel Crunch Cupcake$5.00Chocolate cupcake, caramel sauce in the center, vanilla buttercream frosting, topped with chopped pretzels and chocolate drizzle.Not rated yetVegan

Pumpkin Spice$5.00Pumpkin spice cupcake topped with your choice of: Pumpkin flavored cream cheese frosting, Pumpkin flavored buttercream frosting (available vegan), or Chocolate Buttercream frosting (available vegan). All topped with crushed graham cracker.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Raspberry Filled$4.00Chocolate cake, raspberry filling, & raspberry cream cheese frostingNot rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Red Velvet$4.00Red Velvet cake, cream cheese frosting with red sugarNot rated yet

Shark Bite Cupcake$5.00Vanilla or Chocolate cupcake decorated in an ocean blue swirl frosting and topped with edible sugar art. Vegan option will include plastic shark fin pick instead.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

S'Mores$4.00Chocolate cake, marshmallow cream cheese filling, chocolate frosting, chocolate and marshmallow drizzle with a graham cracker topping.Not rated yetGluten-free

Strawberry Filled$4.00Yellow cake, homemade strawberry filling, w/vanilla & strawberry frosting and dusted with red sugar.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Gender Reveal Cupcakes (4-pack)$20.00Vanilla and/or Chocolate cupcake filled with either "Blue" or "Pink" frosting. Topped with vanilla and/or chocolate buttercream frosting and a mixture of blue and pink sprinkles. If both cupcake and buttercream options are chosen, you will receive 2 of each.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Samoa$5.00Chocolate cupcake topped with coconut and caramel flavored frosting. Then dusted with toasted coconut and chocolate and caramel drizzle.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

PB&J$5.00Vanilla cupcake filled with our signature peanut butter filling. Topped with peanut butter frosting and your choice of fruit.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Chocolate Orange Cream$5.00Chocolate cupcake filled with our own orange cream filling and topped off with orange flavored frosting and a chocolate. Vegan option will have orange frosting in middle and no chocolate topper.Not rated yetGluten-freeVegan

Cookies & Brownies

Colossal Brownie$6.00Decadent triple chocolate Colossal Brownie, customizable with your choice of Vanilla, Chocolate, Pistachio, or Strawberry Buttercream frosting and your choice of toppings. Approximately 1/2 pound.Not rated yet

Cosmic 1/2 lb Cookie$6.00Almost a half pound of cookie with an ooey gooey center. Available in 10 decadent flavors and 3 gluten-free options. For orders of more than 2 of each flavor, please call the shop directly before ordering.Not rated yet

Chocolates

Oreo Dipped 4-pack$5.50Hand-dipped chocolate covered Oreo's. Each bag contains 2 milk chocolate, 1 white chocolate and 1 dark chocolate. Festively decorated with assorted drizzle and sprinkles.Not rated yet

Pretzel Sticks Dipped in Chocolate$4.00Chocolate covered pretzel sticks (3 in a package) with assorted chocolate drizzle and sprinkles.Not rated yet

Turtles (2-pack)$5.00Chocolate cup with sweet caramel, pecans, and more chocolate. Available in Dark Chocolate or Milk Chocolate. Gluten-free as well.Not rated yetGluten-free

Biscoff Dipped Chocolate Cookies (5-pack)$5.00Dark chocolate dipped Biscoff cookies (5 in a package)Not rated yet

Dubai Chocolate Box$20.006 hand-crafted milk and dark chocolate cups filled with rich pistachio cream and phyllo crunch. Garnished with crushed pistachios and gold leaf.Not rated yet

Peanut Butter Cups (3-pack)$5.00Milk chocolate peanut butter cups filled with our own peanut butter filling and dusted with crushed peanuts.Not rated yet

Cake Pops

Cake Pops$4.00Vanilla or Chocolate Cake Pops coated in dark chocolate and dusted with sprinkles. Seasonal limited-time flavor: Pumpkin spice cake coated in white chocolate.Not rated yet