New York New York Pizza

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 27, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

“Likely” diet labels: Based on the menu description, not checked by the restaurant. Tell the restaurant about any allergy before you order.

Build your own real NY pizza

Crust alternativesGluten free 12 inch $16. Cauliflower 14 inch $16.Not rated yet

SauceNY NY pizza sauce, pesto or white.Not rated yet

Cheese toppingsMozzarella, ricotta.Not rated yet

Meat toppingsPepperoni, ham, sausage, salami.Not rated yet

Veggie toppingsPeppers, onions, mushrooms, olives, spinach, garlic, tomatoes, pineapple, roasted red peppers, eggplant, fresh basil, banana peppers, jalapeños.Not rated yet

Premium toppingsBacon, chicken, meatball, steak, fresh mozzarella, feta.Not rated yet

NY NY specials

Margherita$19.00Fresh mozzarella, basil, diced tomatoes and garlicNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

NY NY White$19.00Ricotta, garlic and olive oilNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Four Cheese$19.00Mozzarella, cheddar, asiago and muensterNot rated yet

Grandma Pie$19.00Seasoned crust, plum tomatoes, basil, garlic and olive oilNot rated yet

Florentine$19.00Spinach, ricotta, tomatoes and garlicNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Little Italy$19.00Pepperoni, sausage, roasted red peppers and basilNot rated yet

Veggie$19.00Peppers, mushrooms, olives and onionsNot rated yet

Hawaiian$19.00Ham and pineappleNot rated yet

Philly Cheese Steak$19.00Steak, onions, mushrooms and peppersNot rated yet

Buffalo Chicken$19.00Chicken, buffalo chicken mix and mozzarellaNot rated yet

Chicken Alfredo$19.00Chicken and alfredo sauceNot rated yet

BBQ Chicken$19.00Chicken and bbq sauceNot rated yet

Meat Lovers$19.00Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs and baconNot rated yet

NY NY Supreme$19.00Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, olives, onion, ham and peppersNot rated yet

SicilianThick, fluffy, square crust and tomato sauce. $2 for additional toppingsNot rated yet

Appetizers

Mozzarella sticks$8.00Not rated yet

Fried mushrooms$8.00Not rated yet

Fried mac and cheese bites$8.00Not rated yet

Jalapeño poppers$8.00Not rated yet

Fried zucchini$8.00Not rated yet

Manhattan rollsCheese $8. Add pepperoni $1.50Not rated yet

Seasoned fries$6.00Not rated yet

Garlic knots6 for $6, 2 for $3Not rated yet

Garlic bread$6.00Add cheese $1Not rated yet

Meatballs4 for $12, 2 for $8. Add cheese $1Not rated yet

Chicken tenders$11.00Not rated yet

Stromboli, calzone and pizza bowls

Stromboli$13.00Mozzarella, choice of 2 toppings and side of sauceNot rated yet

Calzone$13.00Ricotta, mozzarella and side of sauceNot rated yet

Pizza bowl$13.00Meat bowl or FlorentineNot rated yet

Buffalo wings

6 wings$10.00Not rated yet

10 wings$16.00Not rated yet

20 wings$30.00Not rated yet

30 wings$45.00Not rated yet

Pasta

Marinara$11.00Your choice of penne, spaghetti or fettuccineNot rated yet

Meatballs (2)$13.00Your choice of penne, spaghetti or fettuccineNot rated yet

Meat sauce bolognese$13.00Your choice of penne, spaghetti or fettuccineNot rated yet

Penne alla vodka$14.00Penne with heavy cream, seasoning, vodka and marinaraNot rated yet

Fettuccine alfredo$14.00Rich and creamy alfredo sauce topped with parmesan cheeseNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Chicken parmigiana$16.00Breaded chicken and mozzarella topped with marinaraNot rated yet

Lasagna$15.00Fresh pasta layered with marinara, ground beef, ricotta, parmesan and mozzarellaNot rated yet

Jumbo stuffed shells$12.00Fresh pasta with ricotta, mozzarella and parmesanNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Baked ziti$12.00Fresh baked pasta with ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan and marinaraNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Pasta combo$15.00Half lasagna and 2 stuffed shellsNot rated yet

Eggplant parmigiana$14.00Fresh cut, hand breaded eggplant with mozzarella and marinaraNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Baked eggplant Florentine$16.00Fresh cut, hand breaded eggplant with ricotta, spinach, mozzarella and marinaraNot rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Salads

Garden salad$9.00Onions, green peppers, tomatoes and cucumbersNot rated yet

Caesar salad$9.00Croutons and parmesan cheeseNot rated yet

Chef's salad$12.00Onions, green peppers, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, pepperoncini, ham, turkey and cheeseNot rated yet

Antipasto$12.00Onions, green peppers, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, pepperoncini, ham, salami and cheeseNot rated yet

Greek salad$12.00Onions, green peppers, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, pepperoncini and fetaNot rated yet

Hot and cold subs

Philly cheese$13.00Steak or chicken, cheese, onions, peppers and mushroomsNot rated yet

Meatball parmigiana$13.00Meatball, mozzarella, parmesan and marinaraNot rated yet

Vodka chicken sub$13.00Chicken, heavy cream, seasoning, vodka and marinaraNot rated yet

Chicken parmigiana$13.00Chicken, mozzarella, parmesan and marinaraNot rated yet

Eggplant parmigiana$13.00Eggplant, mozzarella, parmesan and marinaraNot rated yet

Chicken cutlet$13.00Chicken, lettuce, tomato, cheese and mayonnaiseNot rated yet

Ham and cheese$13.00Ham, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaiseNot rated yet

Salami and cheese$13.00Salami, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaiseNot rated yet

Turkey and cheese$13.00Turkey, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaiseNot rated yet

Italian combo$13.00Ham, salami, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, oil, vinegar and mayonnaiseNot rated yet

Desserts

New York cheesecake$6.00Not rated yet

Chocolate cake$6.00Not rated yet

Cannoli$6.00Not rated yet

Zeppoles$6.00Not rated yet