Rusty Pelican - Key Biscayne, FL

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Nov 5, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

“Likely” diet labels: Based on the menu description, not checked by the restaurant. Tell the restaurant about any allergy before you order.

Starters

Oven-Roasted Oysters$32.00Chili Butter, Parmesan, Crispy Shallots, Grilled LemonNot rated yet

Grilled Herb-Marinated Octopus$29.00Spanish Octopus, Crispy Sunchokes, Fingerling Potatoes, Squid Ink EmulsionNot rated yet

Crab Cake$27.00Lump Crab & Shrimp, Roasted Sweet Corn, Mixed Peppers, Chipotle & Ginger Aioli, Fresh ParsleyNot rated yet

Birria Empanada$20.00Salsa Verde, Oaxaca Cheese, Pickled Onion, Birria SauceNot rated yet

Calamari$24.00Tempura Peppers & Onions, Citrus Buffalo AioliNot rated yet

Crispy Brussels Sprouts$19.00Thai Chili, Young Coconut, Basil, MintNot rated yet

Giant Pistachio Cinnamon Roll$19.00Candied Pistachio, Florida Orange Blossom Honey, Pistachio Crème BrûléeNot rated yet

Host S&DAskNot rated yet

Sushi

Crispy Rice Tuna Tartare$21.00Tuna, Yuzu, Tobiko, Spicy Mayo, Furikake, ChivesNot rated yet

Deco Maki$23.00Pink Sticky Rice, Shrimp Tempura, Mango, Cream Cheese, Fried Red Onion, Eel SauceNot rated yet

Spicy Tuna Roll$20.00Avocado Cream, Pickled Serrano & Ginger Dressing, Green Papaya & Mint SlawNot rated yet

Crispy Rice Sampler$29.00Not rated yet

Greens

Classic Caesar Salad$16.00Shaved Parmesan, Garlic Roasted Croutons, Crispy CapersNot rated yet

Florida Mango Salad$18.00Greens, Cucumbers, Florida Mangos, Carrots, Citrus Ginger Dressing, Crispy QuinoaNot rated yet

Brunch

Florida Snapper Sandwich$28.00Lettuce, Tomato, Potato Hay, Pickles, Spicy Remoulade, Rusty FriesNot rated yet

Quesabirria$28.00Corn Tortilla, Cotija Cheese, Pickled Onions, Cilantro, Roasted Corn, Sunny-Side Up Egg, Consommé, GuacamoleNot rated yet

Grass Fed Filet Mignon 8oz (Steak 'n' Eggs)$55.00Fingerling Potatoes & Fried or Scrambled EggsNot rated yet

Golden Shrimp Sandwich$24.00Hoagie Roll, Cajun Remoulade, Golden Shrimp, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles, Fresno Peppers, Rusty FriesNot rated yet

Giant Pistachio Cinnamon Roll$19.00Candied Pistachio, Florida Orange Blossom Honey, Pistachio Crème BrûléeNot rated yet

New York Strip 12oz (Steak 'n' Eggs)$48.00Fingerling Potatoes & Fried or Scrambled EggsNot rated yet

Chilean Sea Bass$49.00Smoked Sweet Plantain Mash, Grilled Pepper, Mango & Papaya SalsaNot rated yet

Nutella And Belgian Chocolate Chip Pancakes$24.00Strawberry Confit, Nutella Lava, Strawberry PowderNot rated yet

Angus Skirt Steak 10oz (Steak 'n' Eggs)$43.00Fingerling Potatoes & Fried or Scrambled EggsNot rated yet

Crispy Whole Local Snapper$45.00Creamy Coconut Orzo, Arugula & Corn Salad, Jalapeno Lime DressingNot rated yet

French Toast$27.00Fluffy Thick-Cut Brioche, Cognac Roasted Golden Apples, Nutella, Cinnamon-Spiced Maple SyrupNot rated yet

Black Angus Ribeye (Steak 'n' Eggs)$64.00Fingerling Smash & Fried or Scrambled EggsNot rated yet

Atlantic Salmon$41.00Garlic Caper Butter Sauce, 50/50 Mash, BroccolliniNot rated yet

Fried Chicken And Waffle$31.00FreeBird Chicken, Belgian Waffle, Sriracha Maple SyrupNot rated yet

Fish Tacos$24.00Blackened Corvina, Chipotle Aioli, Mango & Papaya Lime Salsa, Rusty FriesNot rated yet

24-Karat Lobster Benedict$42.00Lobster Thermidor, Poached Cage-Free Eggs, Champagne Béarnaise, Fresh Black Truffle, Gold LeafNot rated yet

Lobster Grilled Cheese$34.00Melted Cheddar Cheese, Garlic Aioli, Tomato, Brioche Bun, Rusty FriesNot rated yet

Crab Cake Benedict$32.00Lump Crab and Shrimp, Poached Eggs, Toasted Brioche, Fingerling Potatoes, Chipotle HollandaiseNot rated yet

Brunch Board For Two$135.00Lobster Benedict, New York Strip, Fried Chicken and Waffle, Fingerling PotatoesNot rated yet

Fried Chicken Sandwich$24.00Not rated yet

Surf And Turf$86.00Filet Mignon 8oz and Butter Poached Lobster Tail, Goat Cheese Peruvian Potatoes, Grilled BroccoliniNot rated yet

Croissant Royale$41.00French Omelette, Giant Croissant, Kaluga Caviar, Crème Fraiche, Applewood Bacon, Gold LeafNot rated yet

Tomahawk Ribeye Steak$160.00Arugula & Corn SaladNot rated yet

Guava Stack Pancakes "Pastelito Style"$25.00Guava Coulis, Mascarpone Cream Cheese, Orange SegmentsNot rated yet

Tomahawk Surf & Surf$250.00Tomahawk, Butter Poached Whole Lobster, Shrimp, 50/50 Mash, Potato Hay, Chives, Arugula & Corn Salad, Jalapeno Lime Dressing, Chimichurri, ButterNot rated yet

Berry Boujee French Toast$28.00Strawberry and Cherry Blossom Cream, Brûléed Lemon Curd, Mixed Berries, Whipped Crème FraîcheNot rated yet

Biscayne Burger$24.00Double Patty Smash Burger, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheddar Cheese, Secret Sauce, Caramelized Onions, Brioche Bun, Rusty FriesNot rated yet

The Green Routine$19.00Piña Colada Overnight Oats, Electrolyte Compote, Whole-Grain Sourdough Avocado Toast, Grapefruit BrûléeNot rated yet

The Lobster Mac & Cheese$59.00Half Lobster, Herb Butter, Fresh Rigatoni, Smoked Gouda, Gruyère, American Cheddar, Garlic BreadcrumbsNot rated yet

Thai Coconut Mussels$32.00PEI Mussels, Lemongrass-Red Curry Broth, Thai Basil, Cherry Tomatoes, Toasted BaguetteNot rated yet

Dry-Aged Burger$28.008oz Dry-Aged Beef Patty, New School American Cheese, Bacon-Onion Marmalade, Chili Crisp AioliNot rated yet

Sides Matter

Caviar & Black Truffle Twice-baked Potato$31.00Truffle Mash, Caviar, Ikura, Vodka Crème FraîcheNot rated yet

Garlic Fries$11.00Parmesan, Rosemary, ParsleyNot rated yet

50/50 Mash$11.00Yukon Gold Potatoes, Butter, Cream, Chives, Potato HayNot rated yet

Smoked Sweet Plantain Mash$12.00Not rated yet

Applewood Smoked Bacon$8.00Not rated yet

Two Cage Free Eggs$8.00Not rated yetLikely Vegetarian

Fingerling Potatoes$8.00Not rated yet

Belgian Waffle$8.00Not rated yet

Side Caesar Salad$6.00Not rated yet

Side Garden Salad$6.00Not rated yet

Roasted Spring Vegetables$13.00Not rated yet

Dessert

Key Biscayne Pie$14.00Graham Cracker Crumbs, Key Lime Curds, Toasted MeringueNot rated yet

Café Con Leche Lava Cake$14.00Cookies & Cream Ice Cream, Chocolate Covered Espresso BeansNot rated yet

Warm Bread Pudding$18.00Brioche Bread, Pecans, Whisky Caramel Sauce, Dulce De Leche Ice CreamNot rated yet

Chocolate Explosion$18.00Dark Chocolate Mousse, Brownie, Hazelnut Cream, MarshmallowNot rated yet

Kids Menus

Kids Smash Burger$9.00Beef Patty, Cheddar Cheese, Rusty FriesNot rated yet

Petite Filet Mignon$24.00Rusty FriesNot rated yet

Kids Homemade Pasta$13.00Choice of Butter Sauce, White Sauce or Red SauceNot rated yet

Kids Seared Salmon$19.0050/50 Mashed Potato, Grilled BroccolliniNot rated yet

Kids Mac 'n' Cheese$11.00Mozzarela and Cheddar Cheese BlendNot rated yet

Kids Roasted Chicken$16.0050/50 Mashed Potato, Grilled BroccolliniNot rated yet

Kids Chicken Strips$13.00Rusty FriesNot rated yet