Salt Shack On The Bay

Menu read from the restaurant’s website; prices last checked Oct 30, 2026. Not yet verified by the owner. Tap a dish or drink to see how it ranks. Wrong price?

STARTERS

Shack Style Calamari Rings$12.25Calamari lightly dusted and fried with peppers. Served with our house-made “Island Sofrito Sauce.”Not rated yet

Shack Wings$15.25Ten wings in your choice of either Salt Shack Datil Pepper BBQ Sauce or Jerk Sauce. Served with ranch dipping sauce.Not rated yet

Gaspar's Tuna Tartare$15.25Old Florida recipe with avocado, seaweed salad, sesame and ginger soy drizzle and wasabi aioli. Topped with sesame seeds and green onion.Not rated yet

Smoked Mahi Fish Spread$11.75Nachman’s famous family recipe from Redington Shores.Not rated yet

Coconut Fried Shrimp$18.99Large, wild caught hand breaded in sweet coconut flakes. Served with a citrus mustard sauce.Not rated yet

Fresh Fish Bites$17.25Lightly breaded fresh gulf fish pieces with Shack seasoning and our house made Tarter sauce.Not rated yet

Ceviche$15.25Ask your server for today’s selection. Classic style fresh wild caught shrimp, conch or fish with housemade tortilla chips.Not rated yet

Fried Oysters$12.50Wild Caught - Gulf Oysters seasoned with our special Shack seasoning and fried until golden brown. Served with our house made tartar sauce.Not rated yet

Gator Bites$13.25Lightly breaded fresh gator pieces dusted with Shack seasoning and our housemade gator sauce.Not rated yet

BASKETS

Shrimp Basket$22.00Large, wild caught, lightly breaded shrimp. Served with French Fries, and Guava Cocktail Sauce.Not rated yet

Coconut Shrimp Basket$22.00Large, wild caught hand breaded in sweet coconut flakes. Served with French Fries and Citrus Mustard Sauce.Not rated yet

Fresh Fish Basket$20.00Lightly breaded fresh gulf fish pieces with Shack seasoning and our house made Tartar sauce. Served with French Fries.Not rated yet

Chicken Tender Basket$15.00Crispy Chicken Tenders served with French Fries and our house made Citrus Mustard Sauce. Get them tossed in either Salt Shack Datil Pepper BBQ Sauce or Jerk Sauce with a side of house made Ranch Dipping Sauce.Not rated yet

SOUPS & SALADS

Lobster Bisque$8.75A mild rich and creamy base with lobster pieces.Not rated yet

Bahamian Conch Chowder$7.25Homemade daily. A classic red chowder from Exuma.Not rated yet

House Salad$5.25Fresh greens with tomato, cucumber, onion and shredded cheese. Choice of dressing. Make it a Caesar for $5.95.Not rated yet

Avocado Shrimp Salad$24.00Fresh avocado, grilled shrimp over chopped romaine lettuce with House-made Citrus Vinaigrette. Topped with fresh tomato mango salsa.Not rated yet

Classic Caesar with Reggiano Cheese & CroutonsGrilled chicken $15.50 Grilled shrimp $24.00Not rated yet

SHELLFISH

Oysters$18.00Raw, shucked on the half shell. 1/2 dozen $18.00 1 dozen $36.00Not rated yet

Clams$15.5018 Steamed Fresh Florida Middle Neck Clams in a garlic herb broth.Not rated yet

Shrimp$11.95Domestic Wild Caught Shrimp Steamed or Cold peel & eat. 1/2 pound $11.95 1 pound $19.95Not rated yet

HANDHELDS & BURGERS

Day Boat Fish$25.00Fresh gulf fish fried, grilled, or blackened on a brioche bun. Served with Caribbean tartar and marinated onion straws.Not rated yet

Coastal Crab Cake Sandwich$19.00Broiled Jumbo Lump crab cake, drizzled with Key Lime Aioli served on a Brioche bun with lettuce and tomato.Not rated yet

Shack Shrimp Burger$16.75House made with wild caught shrimp, onions, peppers, Shack seasoning, and sauteed to perfection. Served on a brioche bun with lettuce and tomato. Served with our house made tartar sauce.Not rated yet

Island Chicken Sandwich$14.00Marinated, grilled and glazed with a house-made jerk sauce. Served on a Brioche bun served with lettuce, tomato, onion straws and house-made ranch.Not rated yet

Jerk Pulled Pork Sandwich$13.75On our toasted warm bun, Pulled Pork, Bajan BBQ sauce, jicama slaw. Served with a side of the Bajan BBQ.Not rated yet

Jerk Burger$14.751/2 lb. house-made burger seasoned with authentic Jamaican spices. Topped with carmelized onions, jerk sauce and pepper jack cheese.Not rated yet

Bacon Cheeseburger$14.751/2 lb. house-made burger with Applewood smoked bacon, white cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion.Not rated yet

TACOS

Fish Tacos$17.00Freshly blackened served on flour tortillas with shredded cheese, avocado, jicama slaw, cilantro, and tomato mangosalsa . Drizzled with Chili Horseradish. Fresh Mahi $17.00 Fresh Grouper $18.25 Wild Caught Shrimp $22.00Not rated yet

Island Chicken Tacos$13.75Chargrilled chicken served on flour tortillas with shredded cheese, avocado, cilantro, shredded lettuce, and tomato mango salsa. Drizzled with Chili Horseradish. Ask for it “Shack Style” to add house-made Jerk Sauce.Not rated yet

Jerk Pulled Pork Tacos$13.75Pulled Pork served on flour tortillas with jicama slaw, mango salsa, avocado, cilantro. Drizzled in Bajan BBQ sauce.Not rated yet

FROM THE LAND & SEA

Coastal Crab Cake$26.25Broiled Jumbo Lump crab cakes with Roasted Red Pepper Sauce and Caribbean vegetables set atop marinated onion straws.Not rated yet

Grilled Gulf Shrimp$26.25Large, wild caught shrimp with Shack seasoning. Served with rice and peas and jicama slaw. Side of guava cocktail.Not rated yet

Chimichurri Steak$23.35Mojo Marinated skirt steak topped with house-made Chimichurri. Served with Caribbean vegetables and fried yuca.Not rated yet

Island Grilled Chicken$17.00Organic chargrilled chicken breast finished with house made jerk sauce. Served with Coconut Rum Sauce and Caribbean vegetables, rice & peas.Not rated yet

Shack Seafood Pasta$29.00Linguine tossed with a white wine garlic butter sauce, wild caught-gulf shrimp and fresh middle neck clams. Finished with blistered tomatoes and fresh parsley.Not rated yet

CATCH OF THE DAY

Fire Grilled$30.00With Lemon Garlic Herb Butter.Not rated yet

Pan Seared$30.00Served blackened with a Coconut Rum Sauce.Not rated yet

Whole Fried Fish$36.00Seasoned with Shack Seasoning, lightly floured and deep fried. Served with Caribbean rice and peas, garnished with a house made Escovitch.Not rated yet